A Kinect powered Star Wars game sounds simultaneously great and worrisome. The on-rails game demoed during E3 looked like it had potential, but, as reader lowkevmic points out, we don't know nearly enough about the game at this point to have any real sense of what the game will eventually end up being, or if it will even be the kind of game Star Wars actually want.
It's reached a point where you can no longer say if an upcoming game is going to be good or not until it is out. We all thought the Kinect was going to be crap, and everyone is eating their words. We though the PSPGo was going to be awesome, and you see where that went. For all we know this upcoming star wars game could be the best thing to come to the Kinect, or the fanboys can be right and it can just be crap. But I doubt that the fanboys will be right about this one.