Follow G4 on Twitter
X

TheFeed

UPDATE: 38 Infinity Ward Employees File Lawsuit Against Activision Over Royalties, Alleges Devs Held "Hostage"

pklepek
91 Comments

Posted April 27, 2010 - By pklepek




UPDATE 2:53 PM: Activision has issued a brief response to the lawsuit:

"Activision believes the action is without merit," said a company spokesperson over e-mail just moments ago. "Activision retains the discretion to determine the amount and the schedule of bonus payments for MW2 and has acted consistent with its rights and the law at all times. We look forward to getting judicial confirmation that our position is right.

ORIGINAL STORY: The other shoe has now dropped.

I've obtained a copy of a lawsuit filed this morning in the Los Angeles Superior Court by 38 plaintiffs, calling themselves the "Infinity Ward Employee Group," against Activision. The Infinity Ward Employee Group (whom I'll refer to as IWEG throughout the rest of this story) alleges breach of contract, breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing, violation of California labor code and more. The group is after a large amount of unpaid royalties.

"Activision owes my clients approximately $75 million to $125 million dollars," said Bruce Isaacs, one of the IWEG's attorneys at Wyman & Isaacs LLP, over the phone this afternoon. "Activision has withheld most of the money to force many of my people to stay, some against their will, so that they would finish the delivery of Modern Warfare 3. That is not what they wanted to do. Many of them. My clients' entitled to their money. Activision has no right to withhold their money -- our money."

The IWEG contains "a significant portion of the members of the creative team" who "designed, developed and delivered" Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 to Activision. According to the lawsuit, $28 million has been delivered to Infinity Ward employees for bonuses related to Modern Warfare 2, but the suit alleges at least $54 million is still due from 2009 profits alone.

They want more than $54 million, however. The IWEG is looking "to recover between $75 million and $125 million, if not more, in compensatory damages." That number's derived from:

  • Unpaid bonuses from 2009 and 2010 sales generated by Modern Warfare 2 -- fourth quarter 2009 and first quarter 2010, specifically.
  • Bonuses "due and owing to them" past first quarter 2010.
  • "Bonus/royalty/profit participation" related to "technology/engine" royalties, "other special performance bonuses," "other studio bonuses" or "any other bonus/royalty/profit participation."'
  • Lost value on "restricted stock units" that Activision "promised" would vest (read: own it in your own name and purchase it from Activision) when Modern Warfare 2 sales eclipsed Modern Warfare 1, which "has long ago occurred."
  • Money owed as it relates to Modern Warfare 2 "sister games, including but not limited to" the oft-mentioned Modern Warfare 3, "if Modern Warfare 3 is ultimately delivered and marketed."
  • Interest rates related to the above sums of money.

The lawsuit focuses on royalties generated for Modern Warfare 2 following release and the agreement between Infinity Ward employees and Activision for receiving the subsequent bonuses. The IWEG contends the only condition for becoming eligible for said bonuses was delivering Modern Warfare 2 in time for the game's intended November 10, 2009 launch. Modern Warfare 2 did launch as scheduled on November 10 last year, generating $1.1 billion in 2009.

Modern Warfare 3 has been mentioned during the legal back-and-forth between ex-Infinity Ward leadership Vince Zampella and Jason West and Activision, and it's brought up again here, too.

The IWEG alleges Activision has "improperly withheld this specifically identifiable sum of money from the members of IWEG in order to force them to keep working for Activision so that Activision could receive delivery of Modern Warfare 3." The suit alleges Activision "made a calculated, purposeful and malicious decision" to withhold proper bonuses "in an attempt to force employees of Infinity Ward to continue to work at a job that many of them did not want just so Activision could force them to complete the development, production and delivery of Modern Warfare 3."

The legal language gets harsher, too.

"In short," reads the lawsuit, "Activision withheld the property of the IWEG in an attempt to keep the employees hostage so that Activision could reap the benefit of the completion of Modern Warfare 3."

What does the IWEG want in return? "At least in the additional amount of $75 million to $500 million as an award for punitive damages," continues the lawsuit, citing a number calculated from the blockbuster sales of Modern Warfare 2 and "Activision's net worth."

The IWEG also believes Activision violated California Labor Code during their alleged failure of payment.

"Activision has a duty to pay all of the members of the IWEG all of the money they are owed [...] within 72 hours of the termination of their employment," reads the lawsuit. "Activision, however, has failed to do so."

The full list of plantiffs mentioned in the suit (not all of them have left Infinity Ward): Todd Alderman, Frank Gigliotti, Roger Abrahamsson, Brad Allen, Mohammad Alavi, Richard Baker, Chad Barb, Keith Bell, Chris Cherubini, Taihoon William Cho, Chris Dionne, Joel Emslie, Robert Field, Steve Fuduka, Robert Gaines, Chance Glasco, Preston Glenn, Joel Gompert, Chad Grenier, Mark Grigsby, John Haggerty, Jacob Michael Keating, Chris Lambert, Ryan Lastimosa, Fairfax S. McCandlish IV, Jason McCord, Brent Mcleod, John Paul Messerly, Stephen Miller, Zied Rieke, Jon Shiring, John Slayback, Richard Smith, Geoffery Smith, Jiesang Song, Todd Sue, Rayme C. Vinson and Lei Yang. All are represented by Wyman & Isaacs LLP located in Los Angeles.

Bold claims. I've reached out to Activision for comment.

Clearly, however, the drama involving Infinity Ward is far from over.

Have something to share? Sitting on a news tip? E-mail me. You can also follow me on Twitter.

UPDATE: 38 Infinity Ward Employees File Lawsuit Against Activision Over Royalties, Alleges Devs Held "Hostage"
http://www.g4tv.com/thefeed/blog/post/704273/update-38-infinity-ward-employees-file-lawsuit-against-activision-over-royalties-alleges-devs-held-hostage/
http://files.g4tv.com/ImageDb3/233940_S/Infinity-Ward-Employee-Group-Files-Lawsuit-Against-Activision-Over-Unpaid-Royalties-Alleges-Devs-Held-Hostage.jpg
BlogThread_704273
  • retrocandy

    i think all of you nerds need to get a life and a girlfriend and lose your virginity before you turn 50. watching porn, dateing on xbox or ps3 does not count... my friend david is a total nerd and im willing to bet 500 dollars that he could lose his virginity before you(: please reply with creative critisism don't be a douche.

    Posted: May 12, 2010 9:55 AM | Reply | Report
    retrocandy
  • RONIN1311

    IW was talking about being unhappy about MW and wanting to pursue other interests, they signed a contract with Activision (West and Zampella did) that stated after MW2 they were going a different direction for a game and this whole thing just put a chaotic tailspin into that. Now with word coming out that Activision wanted IW to make MW3 it sounds like they're going back on their contractual promise. Good for you IWEG! I'm not about to boycott Activision games, but damn, shady employers over there at Activision. I hope IW can stick through this and maybe go to a different company and continue to give us good games, if not who knows if these guys will even stick together after this?

    Posted: May 4, 2010 5:50 AM | Reply | Report
  • Jagovasaurus27

    I can't believe Bungie is signing with these jerks. If I were Bungie i would have went with EA or strait up Sony. I also would not sign back up with EA if I were Zampella and West, I would go with someone like Bethesda, even though they probably are busy enough with their fallout ownership rights suits. If Zampella and West didn't like EA when they were done with Medal of Honor, I wouldn't try them again.

    The reason I bring up EA is because I remember reading somewhere that West and Zampella had signed with them and made a new development studio, but I don't know how reliable that information was considering it was around April first.

    There is probably some business decision I'm missing here, but signing with West and Zampella would be great for Bethesda, especially for their Fallout games, which could actually have some good shooting and fps combat with the 2 of them leading up the combat department, we wouldn't have to rely on V.A.T.S.

    This seems a little like a sports draft choice, considering these guys are high value free agents, especially after this lawsuit has gone through.

    Posted: May 2, 2010 11:05 PM | Reply | Report
    Jagovasaurus27
  • archemidies

    No kidding. I was excited to play 2 on the pc only to quite after 3 weeks of crappy connections, no pre selected maps, hacks and all around bad gamming experience. I think the developers at IW should be shot for putting out a multiplayer experience that is worse than games back in the 90's.

    Posted: May 2, 2010 11:16 AM | Reply | Report
    archemidies
  • AnActOfGod

    Considering the EPIC FAIL that was and is IWnet for PC, IW is getting what it deserved. Thank god for BFBC:2 and DICE. If MW3 is anything like the glitch/hack plagued MW2, No Flippin thanks n00bs!

    Posted: May 1, 2010 5:18 PM | Reply | Report
  • sillybilly

    this is looking bad for cod4 and mw2 fans. i believe if i understood what i read infinity ward is going to rush modern warfare 3 and its gonna be terrible. not that i blame them. their being forced to make the game and not getting the money they deserve. in the end infinity ward is going to fall, activisions going to be rich(with money and angry consumers) and gamers are going to suffer so to speek.

    Posted: May 1, 2010 5:01 PM | Reply | Report
    sillybilly
  • 1137002

    :( PERIOD(.)!

    Posted: May 1, 2010 1:37 PM | Reply | Report
  • theWolf228

    wow i just don't see why the 2 companies dont just work together.. i mean its all CALL OF DUTY. i mean yeah they have different game types and stuff but still.

    Posted: May 1, 2010 11:46 AM | Reply | Report
  • strawdog

    the ultimate killstreak against activision continues..... nice, lets hope MW3 never sees the light of day and RESPAWN go on to create a FPS as groundbreaking as MW1 was.

    Posted: April 28, 2010 6:55 PM | Reply | Report
    strawdog
  • BR4CR

    Corporate greed is the cause of too much misery in this world. They should sue for their bonuses AND for the legal right to pound the hell out of Kotick and his gang of raiders, it's the least they deserve for their criminal behavior.

    Posted: April 28, 2010 2:18 PM | Reply | Report
    BR4CR
  • Sanzee

    Here we go again

    Posted: April 28, 2010 1:20 PM | Reply | Report
    Sanzee
  • Falconer13

    Did a comparison of today's Activision and EA stock numbers. Activision is at 10.91 points with a decrease of 4.5%, and EA is at 19.65 with a decrease of 0.56%.

    Posted: April 28, 2010 12:52 PM | Reply | Report
    Falconer13
  • ninenightmares

    thank god bungie still exists!!

    Posted: April 28, 2010 12:22 PM | Reply | Report
    ninenightmares
  • Mirby

    So I'm not the only one who finds this hilarious then, eh? I've read elsewhere of people complaining that Activision used to be a good company. That was, what, 30 or so years ago, probably more? Times have changed people. Apparently, the people currently in power (although at this rate, not for long) saw how well MW2 sold and thought, "HEY! MAYBE WE CAN GET IW TO WORK ON MW3 BEFORE WE PAY THEM SO WE GET EVEN MORE MONEY! YEAH!" Apparently, they're seeing the folly of their ways, yet greed is still blinding them to the truth, to what's right. And that truth is that YOU SHOULD'VE PAID THEM!

    Posted: April 28, 2010 11:40 AM | Reply | Report
    Mirby
  • King_Aaron_Moses

    Activision can s*ck at n*t serousily with all the sh*$ Bobby Kotick has done in running is company and just how he portrays himself, He should be killed by the video game gods. Or at least he should be called Bloody Kotex those how know what that means good for you.

    People thought EA was bad it just happens to be all overly big business are bad but you can look the other way if they aren't making noise all the time on how bad they are.

    Activision being gone would be a blessing. I HATE BLOODY KOTEX!!!

    Posted: April 28, 2010 10:33 AM | Reply | Report
    King_Aaron_Moses
  • redscharlach

    So check me out... My boss just got fired. I liked my boss. He started a new company after he left, and I decided to quit my job and join him. Now, I'm suing my old company for money that I MIGHT have earned, HAD I decided to stay. I'm also suing for stock options that I was given that have not vested - disregard the fact that "vesting" is explicitly set up to reward employees for staying with the company until a specific point in time. Keep in mind that everybody owes me everything, and I am not to be held responsible for decisions that I've made about my own life.

    By the way, you know that company that my boss started after being fired? It turns out he was planning on starting that company behind the back of our former employer, using their resources to do so, and colluding with their direct competitor in the process. In other words, the reason he got fired is that he was trying to screw over our old company.

    This whole thing is retarded. We live in an entitlement society where nobody is ever held accountable for having any kind of a brain or educated free will of their own. It surprises me that everyone jumps to the defense of "the poor developers". You pull any of this crap in any other industry, and you're toast. Yet, for some reason, everyone thinks it's okay because it's game development? How does that work?

    Posted: April 28, 2010 8:55 AM | Reply | Report
    redscharlach
  • backerman

    IW will be Respawn!

    Posted: April 28, 2010 6:09 AM | Reply | Report
    backerman
  • infamouscole15

    activision-blizzard is gonna win its a billion dolla company...............

    Posted: April 28, 2010 3:45 AM | Reply | Report
    infamouscole15
  • scottyrob82

    The fall of an empire.

    Posted: April 28, 2010 3:17 AM | Reply | Report
    scottyrob82
  • Chashu

    they should make a game based on these events. just add guns

    Posted: April 28, 2010 2:19 AM | Reply | Report
    Chashu

Add a Comment

Limit 5,000 characters | 5,000 characters remaining
Log in to Comment
Post to Facebook
Post to Facebook

ADVERTISEMENT

Blog Tags

g4tv.com

AdChoices