X

Do You Take Requests? A Wishlist for This Year’s Music Games

G4Sterling
35 Comments

Posted March 9, 2010 - By G4Sterling

Rock Band 2

If you hadn’t heard, Harmonix officially announced Rock Band 3 earlier today. And after plenty of deliberation, I decided it was a good time to rattle off a wishlist of gameplay elements I’d love to see make the cut in both Harmonix’s new game and the inevitable Guitar Hero 6. To me, tracklisting worries have become progressively less relevant as the music industry clamors to revitalize itself through these games. It’s more important to focus on the ease of use at this point. After all, a few seconds of menu fidgeting can bring down the buzz at a house party very quickly.

Although everyone’s casting a gloomy forecast for music and rhythm games in 2010, I’m looking forward to both efforts -- after all, it’s not like I played every band-branded Guitar Hero game -- and sincerely hope that we’ll see some of the following features implemented:

Personalized Playlists -- Look, my wife hates AC/DC. It’s claws on a blackboard to me when she wants to play The Cranberries. It’s only going to hurt more when Rock Band Network gives us new songs out the wazoo. Personalized playlists are a great workaround for this. I’m sick of yelling “shut up and sing, dammit” every time “War Pigs” randomly shows up during Career Mode in Rock Band 2. Yes, I’m a terrible husband, I admit it, but that's beside the point.

Not Just Custom Playlists, the Ability to Toggle Tracks -- I want the option to toggle songs on/off of playlists, but not my hard drive. I don’t want to delete songs, I just want more control over what a “random setlist” defines. (read: no Fallout Boy, ever). And yes, this ties into Career Mode, since it’s pretty annoying to randomly encounter some song that’s utterly repulsive or is “Say It Ain’t So.”

Support for Multiple Vocals -- Not every band has the pipes of the Beatles, but I’d love to see the next iterations of Rock Band and Guitar Hero boast support for multiple singers. Harmonix has set expectations for vocal harmonizing with The Beatles: Rock Band, and it’d be a pity to see it trimmed from future iterations. Between the likes of SingStar and Lips, there’s room for multiple mics. Unless you’re playing on Wii, but then, I have no easy solutions for that. A better USB hub, perhaps?

Universal Calibration Settings -- I’m glaring at you on this one, Guitar Hero. Amidst a year of market saturation that threatened to kill the genre, and none of those four major Guitar Hero SKUs share the same TV calibration? Insanity. Nothing kills Guitar Hero 5 and Band Hero’s awesome Party Mode feature like spending 20 minutes noodling around in menus.

Instant Calibration Feedback -- The only thing arguably more irritating than the lack of universal calibration is the inability to immediately test it out. Instead, I’ve got to backtrack through several menus, wait for the song to load, miss a litany of notes, and...derp. An option that lets me immediately tweak a song, then jump back in, is most desirable at this point.

Disc Swap -- SingStar’s been doing this for years. If Guitar Hero is going to restrict the amount of songs per-disc I can slap on my hard drive, why can’t GH6 recognize tracks from prior releases and load them up?

Nearly three years after Guitar Hero III and Rock Band, are there any major gameplay or interface tweaks you’d like to see make the experience go smoother?

Do You Take Requests? A Wishlist for This Year’s Music Games
http://www.g4tv.com/thefeed/blog/post/703090/do-you-take-requests-a-wishlist-for-this-years-music-games/
http://files.g4tv.com/ImageDb3/138912_S/Rock-Band-2.jpg
BlogThread_703090
  • Mystyr_E

    I don't know if it's part of Rock Band 2 or Beatles but is there any way to see if you've bested the previous score you had on that song? Think it be a cool way to encourage practice if you can see like a "+2000" score like in racing when you beat your lap record

    Posted: March 11, 2010 10:20 AM | Reply | Report
    Mystyr_E
  • Adampro123

    I would like if they added a keyboard into it. and also have some more up to date songs.

    Posted: March 10, 2010 2:53 PM | Reply | Report
    Adampro123
  • Notafanboythatiknow

    My wish is for the Guitar Hero franchise to disappear. But Rock Band probably needs some competition (regardless of how mediocre it is). I agree with your points Sterling. About the calibration issues. Isn't that a problem with Guitar Hero? I never calibrated Rock Band games and never have had any issues.

    P.S. wouldn't a keyboard peripheral be great.

    Posted: March 10, 2010 2:25 PM | Reply | Report
    Notafanboythatiknow
  • BertSaxby

    Oh, and I forgot. How about some Def Leppard , Aldo Nova and Scorpions?

    Posted: March 10, 2010 12:01 PM | Reply | Report
    BertSaxby
  • BertSaxby

    More custom track difficulties. In other words, more complex chords can be selected on the easy speeds and less complicated ones at higher speeds. Ultimately this would result in reducing the barrier to learning new tracks, improving skills and extending playability.

    Posted: March 10, 2010 11:54 AM | Reply | Report
    BertSaxby
  • babyteeth219

    I flushed over 300 dollars into rockband by downloading content and REdownloading content. I purchased 3 xbox360's. The list of atrocities are to much to count. my brother has done the same. I know we are not the only ones. even after all of this people still continue to purchase a garbage product! I will never purchase another Microsoft product again.

    Posted: March 10, 2010 11:22 AM | Reply | Report
    babyteeth219
  • BONERJAM

    I dont care so much about features but I want music. I want some Chuck Berry, Led Zeppelin(wont happen, I know), Pink Floyd, more Mastodon and Johnny Cash just to name a few.

    Posted: March 10, 2010 10:26 AM | Reply | Report
    BONERJAM
  • gambit1023

    Getting rid of the results screen in between songs while playing a set list on RB would be nice. It really grinds my gears(thank you peter griffin) when after finishing a song with a big rock ending and having to wait 30-45 seconds while it tells me how many stars I got. Who cares about the stars, I just wanna play the song. But at least RB is going back to it's roots and dropping band based games. Now if we could get some more classic rock thrown in.

    my 5 songs I'd like to see:

    U2-Bad(the drum part would be intense)
    Phil Collins-Take Me Home(dont laugh it's a good song and another cool drum beat)
    Ozzy-Crazy Train
    Guns n Roses-Paradise City
    Queensrhyche---The entire Operation Mindcrime album

    Posted: March 10, 2010 10:18 AM | Reply | Report
    gambit1023
  • Tmidiman

    How about more Jazz-Fusion! Those would make great challanging songs for guitar, bass, and drums. Jeff Beck's "Scatterbrain" was a good start on GH5, but where's the rest?

    There is more music in the world than just joe rock music.

    Oh and make it so multiple instruments can practice.

    Posted: March 10, 2010 9:54 AM | Reply | Report
    Tmidiman
  • daespryng

    I'd love for there to be lead and rythem track for guitars. I want to have dueling guitars aka Judas Priest.

    Posted: March 10, 2010 8:47 AM | Reply | Report
    daespryng
  • Digran

    Wishlist:

    1. Multiple Vocal Tracks. Beatles Rock Band spoiled me there. (Come on Bohemian Rhapsody!)
    2. Calibration. Have a test song to check it on.
    3. Rhythm Guitar. When Available. Give Bass/Lead/Rhythm as options but still only 2 Guitars.
    4. Random Toggle. Be able to remove some songs from the Random Select options.
    5. Higher level of Character Customization. I kind of want realism. I'm not ripped like Kratos. Maybe I should do situps instead of play Rockband, but then we wouldn't be having this conversation.
    6. Profanity filter. I'm tired of filling in the curse words myself and having people look at me funny when I fill in the "Mommy Breakdown" in "Down with the Sickness"
    7. Countdown to Resume after pause. Nothing more frustrating then losing your 1k streak to a bandmate pausing instead of activating star power.
    8. Jukebox mode. They put a lot of time into the background band performance and I enjoy it. In conjunction with the Random Toggle I'd like to hit play on the songs I paid $2 each for.
    9. Overdrive/Star Power button activation for Vocals. Don't take out the current system, just add in a controller option. Some of the activation points are my only chance to breathe.
    10. Clothing Packs. Keep the store from becoming useless.

    Posted: March 10, 2010 8:25 AM | Reply | Report
    Digran
  • Echo5585

    How about better online play where when someone in your party drops out you don't lose the song and get totally screwed? Has happened so many times...

    Posted: March 10, 2010 8:23 AM | Reply | Report
    Echo5585
  • colffenstein

    Set up big tours instead of just doing the events. Set up you show to have explosives go off at certain times. Of course there could be an autoshow mode but it would be awesome to be able to customize your stages and events that happen during your show like crowd surfing, explosions, lightshows, smashing instruments at end, etc. It would be awesome!

    Posted: March 10, 2010 7:38 AM | Reply | Report
    colffenstein
  • colffenstein

    Downloadable Musicians! That would be really cool to play as my favorite musicians without having to buy a full game for them. And maybe a feature where each song in you playlist is performed by the actual band that the song was made by.

    Posted: March 10, 2010 7:36 AM | Reply | Report
    colffenstein
  • HereComesDan

    When are they going to come out with Theremin Hero?

    Posted: March 10, 2010 7:28 AM | Reply | Report
  • HereComesDan

    When are they going to come out with Theremin Hero?

    Posted: March 10, 2010 7:27 AM | Reply | Report
  • Nightfirewlf

    How about a Rock Band designed specifically for a genre of music? You could make amazing visuals for a entire genre instead of a collection of them. (I.E. The Beatles Rock Band) I would gladly pay big money for a M-rated Metal super playlist with a theme to every song.

    Also I want customizable stages, not legos in the form of a stage.
    And maybe, just maybe just a little more Queens of the Stone Age

    Posted: March 10, 2010 6:41 AM | Reply | Report
    Nightfirewlf
  • xN7 SNiiPer209x

    they need to spend the big bucks on Rock Band 3 and get the bands that everyone loves: metallica, linkin park, kiss, dream theater, disturbed, and many others...

    Posted: March 10, 2010 1:02 AM | Reply | Report
    xN7+SNiiPer209x
  • SirCitadel

    i think they should design the guitar with a flat button/pad that runs perpendicular to the strum bar so you can play slap bass. like where GH put the star power button on their new controllers.

    Posted: March 10, 2010 12:08 AM | Reply | Report
    SirCitadel
  • Mystyr_E

    @ JSRG
    let's hope an Activision employee doesn't read G4 comments or else we will be seeing one :P

    Posted: March 9, 2010 11:19 PM | Reply | Report
    Mystyr_E

Add a Comment

Limit 5,000 characters | 5,000 characters remaining
Log in to Comment
Post to Facebook
Post to Facebook

SPONSORED AD

ADVERTISEMENT

Blog Tags

g4tv.com

  • Kevin Pereira's Last Walk Through Attack Of The Show

    Posted: Yesterday 5:30 PM

    15,945 Views | 03:38

    5 / 5

  • Joe Rogan Returns To AOTS

    Posted: Yesterday 5:30 PM

    8,293 Views | 07:42

    5 / 5

  • Alan Wake In-Game Verizon Commercial

    Posted: May 21, 2010

    86,222 Views | 01:37 | 16 Comments

    5 / 5

  • Kevin's Favorite Videos On Around The Net 5.31.12

    Posted: Yesterday 5:30 PM

    3,094 Views | 08:52

    5 / 5

AdChoices