G4TV

News From The Feed

X-Play Best of 2008 Winners List

Posted by Mike D'Alonzo - Tuesday, December 09, 2008 6:05 PM

X-Play has announced its list of winners for the sixth annual X-Play Best of 2008 Awards. The whole list follows, but here is the Game of the Year video. 

 

And now, below the jump, please check out the entire list of winners.

As you can see from the list, Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots was the big winner, with four awards, while Fable II took home the coveted Game of the Year prize, beating out the likes of Resistance 2 and Fallout 3. “The game’s charming settings, elegant combat and accessibility without compromising depth all worked together to create our favorite gaming experience of the year, said Adam Sessler, X-Play Host and Editor in Chief, G4 Games and Content.

“The categories were all very close calls,” said Morgan Webb, Host of X-Play. “And a gamer can’t go wrong choosing any game nominated, winner or not.”

That said, here are your winners, folks. Let us know if you agree or disagree with the decisions made.

Game of the Year

  • Fable II                                    
     

Most Original Game

  • Braid   
     

Best Gameplay Innovation

  • “Level creation/sharing” – LittleBIGPlanet
     

Best Multiplayer Game

  • Left 4 Dead                             
     

Best Action/Adventure Game

  • Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots
     

Best Sports Game

  • Madden NFL 09   
                                  

Best Shooter

  • Left 4 Dead
     

Best RPG

  • Fallout 3 
     

Best New Character

  • Drebin 893 – Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots
     

Best Art Direction

  • LittleBIGPlanet
     

Best Animation

  • NBA 2K9
     

Best Writing

  • Grand Theft Auto IV   
     

Best Original Soundtrack

  • Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots
     

Best Sound Design

  • Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots
     

Best Downloadable Content

  • Rock Band 2 - DLC songs 
      

Best New Downloadable Game

  • Braid
     

Best Strategy Game

  • Sins of a Solar Empire             
     

Best Racing Game

  • GRID   
     

Best Music/Rhythm Game

  • Rock Band 2
     

Best Handheld Game

  • The World Ends With You                                          
     

Best MMO

  • Warhammer Online: Age of Reckoning



Comment(s)

Posted by rbee90 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:20 PM

i still cant believe fable 2 won...i was hoping gears 2, mgs4 or fallout 3...but fable 2? cmonnnnnn

Posted by ctlaltdel - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:21 PM

360 wins again!!! Fable 2 was awesome but I thought Gears 2 or Fallout 3 would win.

Posted by rbee90 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:23 PM

@ctladel(watever)

as an owner of the 2 systems...numuber 1 in my list is mgs4, 2nd is gears, and 3rd is fallout...but fable?...fable? wtf...

Posted by BadHabit209 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:24 PM

Wow did not see that coming.

Posted by BadHabit209 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:25 PM

damn.. really? im a Xbox fan, but i dont think fable should have won this lol

Posted by rbee90 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:25 PM

mgs4 won 4 awards, but didnt get GotY? this is gphoria all over again...super bullcrap...

Posted by SynicVance - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:26 PM

This seems like one of those, all of the shooter fans were split between 4 shooting games and the RPG freaks had only 1 game to choose from. Hence Fable 2 wins.

Posted by ctlaltdel - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:26 PM

@ rbee90

Hey its a great game also I said my pick would have been for Gears 2 or Fallout 3.

Posted by rbee90 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:27 PM

@ctlaltdel

i know! at least those games shoudve won! even RROD thinks gears 2 shoudve won!

Posted by Captainjack8228 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:27 PM

um..great game but GOTY it was not. Gears or Fallout3, definitely.

Posted by komradkyle - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:28 PM

I really enjoyed fable 2 but the game was WAY TOO SHORT way too shallow and just felt like half was missing. Fallout 3 was the most amazing game I played all year, because of the amazing cinematics during VATS combat, dialouge, and 80 hours of gameplay playing all the quests just on one gender and one Karma. but I never played MGS4 I think that would be my second choice

Posted by Waterbear91 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:28 PM

CoD:WaW is my vote...cause i don't like Gears and never played Fable...

Posted by lilme3333 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:28 PM

mgs4,R2,or gears 2(havent played fallout yet)but fable....NO

Posted by lightknight77 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:28 PM

Warhammer as best MMO? I figured WoW would be firmly seated in the throne for years.

Pretty good results. Some I would have done differently, but I guess that's why I'm not getting paid for my opinion... or laid.

Posted by bartonjones - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:29 PM

what no love for the best game of past decade, GTA IV

Posted by SynicVance - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:29 PM

Question: Fable 2 is an RPG yet Fallout 3 won Best RPG? So how can you be GAME OF THE YEAR if you're not even the best RPG. I could understand if the two were swapped and Fallout 3 won GOTY while Fable 2 won RPG, because Fallout 3 is a shooter and an RPG.

Posted by staychisel (BANNED) - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:30 PM

ha! everyone wanted a shooter to win and it didn't. if a fps or 3ps did win then someone would be griping.

fable 2 FTW!

(it's alot of fun, btw)

Posted by halokiller455 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:30 PM

Wow, for once the xbots and sony fans agree on something.

Posted by rbee90 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:30 PM

and gears 2 never won 1 award!!! wtf is happening here?

Posted by rbee90 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:31 PM

@staychisel

cmon dude...even you cud say and admit that gears 2 should have snagged GotY...

Posted by cxhxexexsxe - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:31 PM

i still think it should have been LBP and for best original soundtrack should have been pixeljunk eden, but oh well, i'll just wait for the real thing at the VGA's


P.S i think fable was a decent choice

Posted by lilme3333 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:32 PM

mgs4,R2,or gears 2(havent played fallout yet)but fable....NO

Posted by Estou - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:32 PM

i think i may be the only one here who is excited about the strategy game winner, although i think gal civ 2 (twilight of the arnor) should'v won, im still happy with sins of a solar empire (still pretty amazing). And for game of the year i think i agree with xplay, although i havent played gears 2 or MGS4, i think fable 2 was truly an amazing game (i didnt think fallout 3 was anything special, and left 4 dead just had good multiplayer).

Posted by TomHoang - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:32 PM

Haven't played Fable 2, so I can't really say anything bad about it. Out of the games I did play, I would have to say MGS4.

Posted by halokiller455 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:32 PM

Wow, for once the xbots and sony fans agree on something.

Posted by squirt333 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:33 PM

anybody think its wierd that fable 2 won goty but fallout 3 won best rpg? Interesting list i dont know its not even close to my list though.

Posted by woo - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:33 PM

Fable 2!!!WTF LOL How the hell did this be the game of the year its a great game though but game of the year give me a break. Mgs4 or Gta4 should have won game of the year,im so surprised.LMAO

Posted by BlackPrince42 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:34 PM

Fable 2? Had Gears beat MGS4 my fanboy sensor might have gone off, though GeOW2 is still great, but Fable 2? Also LBP not being nominated for GOTY is a crime in and of itself.

Posted by rbee90 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:34 PM

@halokiller455

even RROD said gears 2 shoudve won GotY...

Posted by DaGreedyKing - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:34 PM

i think xplay got some money under the table
bastards

Posted by dz99ls - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:34 PM

epic fail fable didnt even belong in the nom's

Posted by StonyJAK - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:35 PM

woot Fable 2 won GOTY but everyone got there fair share ecxept gears 2 but at least xbox 360 dudes and ps3 guys got along

p.s. i think PURE should have won racing game

Posted by ThataUFO - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:36 PM

Holy crap, that was bull&%^$. What was FAble II even doing in the running for GOTY?

Posted by JDarkley - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:36 PM

My pick would have been GTA IV, but hey.

Posted by ctlaltdel - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:37 PM

@ rbee90

I'm very suprised that R2 and Gears 2 both got shafted. I figured each game would have got something.

Posted by sctydsnktnow - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:37 PM

GTA IV!

Posted by bartholomew99 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:37 PM

It's not fair to judge as I on't have a 360 but really, Fable 2? Goty? I really don't see it.

I'm just happy that L4D got a couple of well-deserved awards for multiplayers and shooters.

Posted by NakedSnake14 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:38 PM

BSBSBSBSBS how in the hell of mankind, did Fable II of all games win Game of the Year. I own a 360 + PS3 and if MGS4, LBP, R2, or GeOW2 had won I would have been happy. But, Fable II was just a complete load of bull

Posted by mikester3127 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:38 PM

I'm surprised metal gear solid 4 didn't get game of the year but fable 2 is a really good game. and on top of that resistance 2 didn't win anything what's up with that?

Posted by Krystal*Light - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:38 PM

Geez G4 always seems to dissapoint me in their awards show. It's not because of their picks everyone is entitled to their own opinion, but G4 seems not to always understand the genres and which games apply to that genre. For example Dead Space was put along with Action/Adventure category when it's a survival horror and MGS4 was also put into that category as it's a steal action not Action/adventure. The only ones they had that would fit are God of War:CoO,and No More Heroes. They also said they had something for every category when they left out platformer, puzzle, adventure, board-game, and console specific categories.

I am pleased though that MGS won a lot of awards. Someday my game will be on there.

Posted by SUPERX01 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:39 PM

I was at least hoping that DEAD SPACE would be a contender for Game of the Year

Posted by PastItAll - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:39 PM

I can't believe Fable 2 won! I knew that XPlay being the 360 fanboy show that it is would pick a 360 game, but Fable 2? What a horrible pick. It should have been MGS4.

Posted by ricky047 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:39 PM

when adam announces mgs4 like,"another mgs game" lol.

Posted by halokiller455 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:39 PM

Even the people on Fable 2 message boards say Fallout 3 is a better game.

Posted by rbee90 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:40 PM

@ctlaltdel

i know! at least those titles could have snagged 1...im even in utter shock not seeing one award for gears 2...

Posted by staychisel (BANNED) - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:41 PM

@rbee90, true. i was rooting for gears2, but i just think it's funny that a game won that wasn't a shooter for once.

Posted by kyle2dotcom - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:41 PM

I'm sorry every other choice was better then Fable 2. Lets face it. Fable 2 in my honest opinion was not a good game. GTA4 was worse. Honestly Resistance 2 was better then Fable 2...and that game was just ok.

Posted by NakedSnake14 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:41 PM

I think Fable won, because Peter Molyneaux was supposed to be there.

Posted by imisshalo3 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:42 PM

hmm mgs4 won much... good luck ps3

Posted by deleted_C500C119-53DD-4584-B8AF-983D528528D8 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:44 PM

lol fable 2 this site is reta-red fable 2 sucks balls. gears of queers is even better than fable 2. is should of been either fallout 3 or mgs4

Posted by staychisel (BANNED) - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:44 PM

also, to show my non fanboyism side, i think grid sucks and motorstorm is a freakin awesome racing game.

Posted by rbee90 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:44 PM

@staychisel

yep...and gears 2 didnt even have 1 award...hell...even that troll RROD thinks gears 2 shoudve won...

Posted by deleted_A6AF56F4-DA98-49AC-A673-5A686932D6E4 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:45 PM

mgs4 should have swept the goty award, it was flawless, flawless, g4 is smoking that pipe or sniffing that powder

Posted by ctlaltdel - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:46 PM

All I know is that Gears 2 already has my vote for the next G-Phoria when we get to pick!

Posted by CPRxChris - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:47 PM

What I wanted:

Game of the Year-
Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots

Most Original Game-
LittleBigPlanet
or
Mirror's Edge

Best Gameplay Innovation-
LittleBigPlanet
or
Tom Clancy's EndWar

Best Multiplayer Game-
Resistance 2

Best Action/Adventure Game-
Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots
or
Dead Space
or
God of War: Chains of Olympus

Best Sports Game-
FIFA 09

Best Shooter-
Far Cry 2
or
Resistance 2

Best RPG-
Tales of Vesperia

Best New Character
Sackboy - LittleBigPlanet
or
Drebin 893 - Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots

Best Art Direction-
Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots

Best Animation-
Grand Theft Auto IV

Best Writing-
Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots

...

Posted by rbee90 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:47 PM

@staychisel

i even think pure OR motorstorm shoudve won asides from grid...

wow...people are getting along...thanks for the ceasefire G4!!!

Posted by sdc10 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:48 PM

Despite what any of you say Fable II is a GOOD game, im sorry but i just dont see anything wrong with it. Neither do most critics.

Posted by Utmost_NutsZo - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:49 PM

Fable 2 isn't even the best game in it's own genre this year, yet it wins GOTY?

I'm sorry X-Play. That has fail written all over it.

Posted by CPRxChris - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:49 PM

...

Best Original Soundtrack-
Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots

Best Sound Design-
Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots

Best Downloadable Content-
Burnout Paradise - bikes/map expansion
or
Rock Band 2 - DLC songs
or
Warhawk - PSN expansions

Best New Downloadable Game-
Ratchet & Clank: Quest for Booty

Best Strategy Game-
Valkyria Chronicles

Best Racing Game-
Burnout Paradise
or
MotorStorm: Pacific Rift

Best Music/Rhythm Game-
Guitar Hero World Tour
or
Rock Band 2

Best Handheld Game-
God of War: Chains of Olympus

Best M-M-O-
World of Warcraft: Wrath of the Lich King

Posted by deleted_A6AF56F4-DA98-49AC-A673-5A686932D6E4 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:50 PM

i think fable wasnt even a contender , fallout was on a grander , and mgs4 was out of this world

Posted by rbee90 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:50 PM

@CPRxChris

cmon dude.,..fanboys a re getting along...keep up the momentum...dont show your fanboyism crap here...cmon...even you would admit that gears 2 shoudve won instead of fable 2

Posted by sdc10 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:51 PM

Despite what any of you say Fable II is a GOOD game, im sorry but i just dont see anything wrong with it. Neither do most critics.

Posted by staychisel (BANNED) - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:51 PM

i also agree that mirror's edge was one of the most original titles i've played this year

Posted by deleted_A6AF56F4-DA98-49AC-A673-5A686932D6E4 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:53 PM

everyone, lets botcoot g4 for like a month so they can eliminate fable from contention, i rather have gears win goty, this is embarrassing to all fellow gamers, even the xbots, and the bs3 fanboys, we have to veto this

Posted by sdc10 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:53 PM

Despite what any of you say Fable II is a GOOD game, im sorry but i just dont see anything wrong with it. Neither do most critics.

Posted by sp0ck_z0mbi3 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:54 PM

Um...wtf It should been fallout 3 or left 4 dead

Posted by Jab969 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:54 PM

wtf? why did fable 2 get it gow2,r2,fallout3,and or left 4 dead should have gotten it. fable 2 is not a bad game but no game of the year why did they put this as goty.

Posted by metsfan807 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:55 PM

I am a Xbox and PS3 owner and I am truly dumbfounded that Fable II can win GOTY. It is a good game, but all in all, it is gets quite repetitive quickly. The combat system is way to shallow and the "RPG" element is very thin. Very disappointing. Having played them all I would rank Fallout 3 tops (a ton of depth and true RPG elements), LBP 2nd (I know wasn't nominated, but the graphics are amazing and the gameplay/development kit is outstanding), Gears2 a close 3, and MGS4 next (only reason is because it was almost an action movie/game with its cutscenes and frequent load times). All in all, as a gamer we really shouldn't complain about anything. Regardless of what system you own, you have great choices! Own both is my motto, this way you never miss out on anything regardless of exclusives!

Posted by Mexico619 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:56 PM

wtf??? Fable 2 gets boring after the first 6 hours y the hell is this GOTY??? GTA4 should have been GOTY or Gears 2

Posted by LiquidIce21 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:56 PM

why did LBP win best innovation? L4D AI director is ten times more innovative than level creating. It just perfected a formula thats been known for a while. thats not innovation

Posted by MSspartan438 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:56 PM

wow
i loved fable 2
but idk
i would have thought maybe fallout
but i thought the real competition would have been gta 4 and mgs 4

personally i thought gta should have won, it was really good

Posted by Letterboxboy - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:57 PM

The Fact That LittleBugPlanet And Super Smash Bros. Brawl Was Not Nominated For Game Of The Year, Makes This Awards Show An EPIC FAIL!!!!!!!!

STOP BELITTLING NINTENDO AND SONY G4!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted by Vesipham - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:57 PM

Interesting.

Fallout 3 wins Best RPG, but loses Game of the Year to Fable 2, an RPG that didn't win any other awards.

MGS4 won four different awards but didn't get Game of the Year.

Gears of War 2 didn't win ANYTHING.

Posted by rbee90 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:58 PM

dam...that was a short ceasefire...lol

Posted by metsfan807 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 6:58 PM

I am a Xbox and PS3 owner and I am truly dumbfounded that Fable II can win GOTY. It is a good game, but all in all, it is gets quite repetitive quickly. The combat system is way to shallow and the "RPG" element is very thin. Very disappointing. Having played them all I would rank Fallout 3 tops (a ton of depth and true RPG elements), LBP 2nd (I know wasn't nominated, but the graphics are amazing and the gameplay/development kit is outstanding), Gears2 a close 3, and MGS4 next (only reason is because it was almost an action movie/game with its cutscenes and frequent load times). All in all, as a gamer we really shouldn't complain about anything. Regardless of what system you own, you have great choices! Own both is my motto, this way you never miss out on anything regardless of exclusives!

Posted by grunto - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:00 PM

How does Fable 2 beat ot Gears 2 and MGS4 for GOTY? I mean come on, really? And GTA4 has the best writing? I thought people compared MGS4 to being like a movie. And having one of the best plots known to gaming. Yet, GTA4 wins Best Writing? Man, idk how the hell these awards were determined, but it musta been voted on by monkeys throwing poo around or something. How G4 can give huge kudos to a game and then turn around and forget all about it astounds me.

Posted by rbee90 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:01 PM

@grunto

at the monkey throwing poo part...pure genius dude...im lmao here

Posted by deleted_A6AF56F4-DA98-49AC-A673-5A686932D6E4 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:02 PM

this is an outrage, no wii games won an award, and mgs won the most and didnt win goty, and gears and r2 didnt win anything, fallout lost and won against fable 2, g4 is on that pipe

Posted by grunto - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:03 PM

Man sorry G4 but, you know that EPIC FAIL segments you guys do? Yea, uhh, this list deserves a pedestal in that segment. I mean wow... I really..... Jeez.... I think I can safely say this is the first time all flamers, even RROD and Staychisel can agree. This list has FAIL written all over it. Well some categories were right but the GOTY, nope, WRONG!

Posted by rbee90 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:05 PM

@grunto

G4 can bring flame wars, and peace at the same time...what a package!

Posted by bleahy - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:06 PM

Keep it civil guys.

If you disagree, explain why. Why do you think a different game should have won X category, etc.

If you guys just want to bash G4 and X-Play for our choices, fine, but why do that when you can meaningfully contribute to the discussion by talking about your personal GOTY and choices for winner.

Posted by mongy25 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:06 PM

man g4 must be huge 360 fanboys,

no more heroes should have won
best new character and ssbb should have been at least nominated for SOMETHING

and mgs4 is amazing!

stuped 360 fanboys at least if your going to pick a 360 game to win best game pick gears 2 at least that game deseved it.(if you didn't get this by now i hated fable 2)

Posted by XxGodsMistakeXx - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:06 PM

G4 u are this weeks EPic fail last year Halo 3 and now Fable 2 WTF to the max i refuse to accept this... and will go as far to agreeing to whatever RRoD said about this game....


Ps i havent read any of the comments so im just going to assume Rrod posted somewhere hating on Fable and i agree accept if it has to do with Resistance and LBp being Game of the year cause if so kindly blow it out ur ass

Posted by rbee90 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:07 PM

honestly this is my favorite thread so far in this flamed up website...somehow, for the first time, fanboys are getting along...and dam does it look pretty...

Posted by grunto - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:08 PM

rbee90
Lol you crack me up man, but still, you cant deny this list is pretty much a fail.... Still blame it on the monkeys tho lol

Posted by GYZMO8361 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:09 PM

Wow im disappointed

Posted by SonyJunkie - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:09 PM

And you guys say you aren't biased. Come on, Fable 2 beating out LBP, MGS4, even Gears 2. They are some of the highest rated games. And Fable 2 winning game of the year but Fallout beats it out in Best RPG. X-play, you guys make no sense.

Morgan Webb you are a beautiful woman, but this is not what a true gamer would have chosen.

Posted by bleahy - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:09 PM

@jbogs22,

You're one more personal attack post away from being banned.

Posted by rbee90 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:09 PM

@Brian Leahy

you guys better barricade those doors...the fanboys are getting along...

Posted by snazzyboy - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:10 PM

I've never even heard of Braid!! And left 4 Dead best multiplayer game- WHAT!! that game is generic and lame. sigh-and don't get me started of Fable...

Posted by grunto - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:12 PM

@rbee90
I have never seen flamers get along like this before. I DONT KNOW HOW THIS WILL END, AHHH!! Im scared of what may happen lol.... (pitch forks and torchs are on sale at walmart for $1 each, LOAD UP BOYS!!!) lol. Man peace is fun.....

Posted by RedRingOfDeath (BANNED) - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:13 PM

@rbee90

When did I say Gears 2 should have won? Call me what you want but don't put words in my mouth.

Posted by grunto - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:14 PM

@Taarec10
He didnt say it was a failure. He just doesnt completely like everything its trying to achieve. Home isnt for every1. It just may not before him. NOW STAY ON TOPIC! WE HAVE A TRUCE GOING DAMMIT!

Posted by LittleBigRapture - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:14 PM

I really wasn't expecting that. With all the games that came out this year for Fable 2 to win? I thought it was great, but for X play to put over Fallout 3 and Metal Gear Solid 4 is beyond me. Fallout 3 was my favourite game of the year. I love MGS4 but theres just so much damn content in Fallout. One more thing why did Fallout 3 win best RPG while Fable won game of the year, but they are both RPGs?

Posted by rbee90 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:14 PM

@Brian Leahy

you guys better be playing an angry mob version of L4D dude...

Posted by ismael0p - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:14 PM

wtf fable 2
i think any of the other games
deserve more this award
i have fable 2 and its not that great its good but not great
i think mgs 4 should of win

Posted by rbee90 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:15 PM

@RROD

Posted by RedRingOfDeath - Tuesday, December 09, 2008 6:10 PM
I knew G4 would give it to a M$ exclusive but I didn't see Fable 2. I thought they would have gave it to Gears 2 though. I don't think the Xbots even agree with that.

"I thought they would have gave it to Gears 2 though"

Posted by deleted_A6AF56F4-DA98-49AC-A673-5A686932D6E4 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:15 PM

grunto

leahy is the next rrod, the 360 version, which is worse

Posted by theAntiFanboy - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:15 PM

I really thought that it would have been between GTA 4 or MGS 4, not that Fable 2 is a bad game I just did not see it as game of the year material. I also want to ask how in the hell Drebin beat Niko Bellic as best new character?

Posted by LittleBigRapture - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:16 PM

I really wasn't expecting that. With all the games that came out this year for Fable 2 to win? I thought it was great, but for X play to put over Fallout 3 and Metal Gear Solid 4 is beyond me. Fallout 3 was my favourite game of the year. I love MGS4 but theres just so much damn content in Fallout. One more thing why did Fallout 3 win best RPG while Fable won game of the year, but they are both RPGs?

Posted by rbee90 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:17 PM

@grunto

like i said to Leahy...those guys better play an angry mob version of L4D...

Posted by iJericho - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:17 PM

#100 COMMENT!!!!

Posted by deleted_A6AF56F4-DA98-49AC-A673-5A686932D6E4 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:18 PM

i thought sackboy was gonna win best new character

Posted by Leotheo - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:19 PM

Either GTA 4 or FO3 should have been GOTY
I call sick bribery on Fable 2

Also, am I the only one not absolutely disturbed that Drebin won over Niko Bellic? WTF is up with that?

Posted by RedRingOfDeath (BANNED) - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:19 PM

@rbee90

Posted by RedRingOfDeath - Tuesday, December 09, 2008 6:10 PM
I knew G4 would give it to a M$ exclusive but I didn't see Fable 2. I thought they would have gave it to Gears 2 though. I don't think the Xbots even agree with that.



-------Show me where I said that Gears 2 SHOULD have won.

Posted by ichaboddanger - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:20 PM

fable 2 is the worst game i have ever played in my life.

period.

Posted by DarkKnight45757 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:20 PM

Fable 2 has more depth than any other game on that list. It deserves its title. Just because you're all about hardcore doesn't mean non-FPS games suck...Perfect example: Fable 2

Posted by thesilentmole - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:21 PM

I can see why Fable II got it, it was almost my game of the year. The story was quite different from your typical RPG banter and the gameplay was brilliant. That being said, I felt it had a few too many technical flaws to be Game of the Year, but certainly a close second in my book.

I am upset, however, to see that Dead Space didn't get anything. That's my personal game of the year.

And finally, Alone in the Dark should have at least gotten a best soundtrack mention, if not the whole award. Say what you will of that game, the OST is a masterpiece.

Posted by deleted_A6AF56F4-DA98-49AC-A673-5A686932D6E4 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:21 PM

maybe leahy could make an sarcastic excuse to why fable lost to fallout in the rpg awards, and why fallout lost to fable 2 goty awards (fallout 3 is on the ps3 thats why)

Posted by rbee90 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:21 PM

@RROD

but you still think that Gears 2 shoudve won it instead of fable 2...and you knew that an xbox 360 exclusive will win...you just dont know the word peace do ya?

Posted by jbogs22 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:22 PM

IDK how they overlooked the best game ever. GTA 4. Gears is an overrated franchise the campaign is good but multiplayer is just terrible compared to CoD or Halo. MGS4 is proof of a franchise the is barely holding on to life. Resistance 2 was fun but not GOTY. Fable 2 was fun for first 2 hours then just got boring and repetitive and dont get me started on the ending. Fallout 3 was only other game worthy of the goty but still all of those games fall short to GTA 4. GTA 4 was overlooked because it came out in april but it was one of the most fun i have ever had playing a game. it had everything if i wanted to burn out on a hookers face i could if i wanted to walk around hitting shop vendors in the face with a bat i could. The multiplayer isnt the greatest but still fun and the campaign is one that can be played numerous times. So i disagree with everyone and im quite upset how GTA 4 got overlooked.

Posted by theAntiFanboy - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:22 PM

Wow, I just realized that Dead Space did not win in the sound department. MGS had good sound effects but come on Battlefield:Bad Company had better.

Posted by grunto - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:22 PM

@Taarec10
You may not remember this, but in his defense, when(what should be GOTY) MGS4 was about to come out. Bleahy did a, I believe a 4 part spread of the MGS series. As to catch people up with the storyline. And he also did a damn good job of making sure no1, absolutely no1, gave way to any spoilers be the factual or speculative. He may be biased in some ways. But he still knows a good game (or series) when he sees one. I just disagree with Fable 2 being GOTY.

The fact that it took 3 parts, and wrapped up roughly 20 years of story, is one reason, why MGS4 should have won Best Writting. Hell they even said how extraordinary Hideo's ability as a story teller improved between MGS3 and MGS4.

Posted by joeyg143 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:22 PM

MGS4 won a lot of the awards. Seriously, MGS 4 FTW. It's an awesome game...

Posted by mastercolmn - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:23 PM

THIS IS FKING BULLSHYT I DONT EVEN CARE IF I GET BANNED FOR THIS POST THIS IS UTTER BULLSHYT
REASONS FABLE 2? DIDNT EVEN WIN BEST RPG WHAT THE FKING HELL! i dont have a problem with most of the other ones but i genuinly feel that the goty SHOULD have bin between
mgs4
gow2
R2
little big plane
and of course gta IV

BUT SERIOUSLY FABLE? and the best reason BECAUSE THE MOTHER FKING DOG??? CMON G4

Posted by staychisel (BANNED) - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:23 PM

best new character: BRUCEY BABY

or anyone from gta4, which is why they get best writing.

Posted by bleahy - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:23 PM

@grunto,

thanks for the defense, but I'm not biased :P
again, opinion does not equal bias.

Posted by agent_of_chaos - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:24 PM

WTF!
Adam and Morgan have lost all credibility as critics.
Yahtzee is a real game critic.

Posted by rbee90 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:24 PM

@grunto

"Hell they even said how extraordinary Hideo's ability as a story teller improved between MGS3 and MGS4."

uh oh...someone found a loophole...well done dude...this post is getting more controversial than i thought

Posted by grunto - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:24 PM

@rbee90
Peace was nice while it lasted I guess. Too bad it didnt last longer lol. Sorry but RROD hadda go and screw it all up :(

Posted by RedRingOfDeath (BANNED) - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:26 PM

@rbee90

I think that MGS4 should have won but this is G4 so I knew a M$ exclusive would win. However, I thought that they would have given it to Gears 2. I'm sure Fable 2 is a good game but I don't think it's in the same league as MGS4 or the other nominees.

Posted by rbee90 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:26 PM

@grunto

yeah...damn RROD...dont know crap about peace...

Posted by mastercolmn - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:27 PM

lol best reason for fable goty is that damn dog YET the dog didnt win best character its a shame really this is bogus
adam and morgan have lost all respect this was not supposed to even be on the list for goty

Posted by rbee90 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:29 PM

@RROD

i know fable 2 is a good game,RROD! *wink wink*...but yeah, gears 2 OR MGS4 OR fallout 3 shoudve snagged GotY, and those games a re better than fable 2..fable 2 is just so...unexpected...its like getting a girl pregnant at the age of 18 u know wat i mean?

Posted by deleted_A6AF56F4-DA98-49AC-A673-5A686932D6E4 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:30 PM

grunto

it doenst take a genius to recognize a great series like mgs, cod4, halo, gears, but it take an idiot to support a console on which his so called favorite series dosnt even have, dat is like halo fanatics buying a ps3 to play R2, or socom fans buying a 360 to play splinter cell

dont defend this puusssy clot(leahy)

Posted by rbee90 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:30 PM

oh dude! i made a rhyme again! lol! AMAZING!

Posted by theAntiFanboy - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:30 PM

@ leotheo
I hear you man. Considering G4's pick for GOTY I was surprised that the dog from Fable 2 did not get it. Niko was the single most bad ass yet completely convincing characters of the last five years let alone this year.

Posted by jargy1 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:30 PM

I'm just glad GTA4 and MGS4 didn't take GOTY. Everything else is fine, though I'd argue vehemently about the writing in GTA4 and Drebin in MGS4 being a good character. But the important thing is at least X-Play realizes neither of those games is the best of the year.

Posted by jbogs22 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:32 PM

IDK how they overlooked the best game ever. GTA 4. Gears is an overrated franchise the campaign is good but multiplayer is just terrible compared to CoD or Halo. MGS4 is proof of a franchise the is barely holding on to life. Resistance 2 was fun but not GOTY. Fable 2 was fun for first 2 hours then just got boring and repetitive and dont get me started on the ending. Fallout 3 was only other game worthy of the goty but still all of those games fall short to GTA 4. GTA 4 was overlooked because it came out in april but it was one of the most fun i have ever had playing a game. it had everything if i wanted to burn out on a hookers face i could if i wanted to walk around hitting shop vendors in the face with a bat i could. The multiplayer isnt the greatest but still fun and the campaign is one that can be played numerous times. So i disagree with everyone and im quite upset how GTA 4 got overlooked.

Posted by rbee90 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:33 PM

@Brian Leahy

did i mention to get a mod on L4D that lets you fight angry mobs instead of mutated rabies people?...and barricade your doors?...

Posted by mastercolmn - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:33 PM

@jargy1
BOTH those games are more deserving then fable2

the only award it shoulda got was "most repetitive" and possibly "the one game you WONT replay again"

Posted by deleted_A6AF56F4-DA98-49AC-A673-5A686932D6E4 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:34 PM

leahy thinks he smart and untouchable , he is just a plain example of a person with no imagination(expalins why he doesnt favor home) and a mindless fool that just want to shoot zombies all day(L4D was that great)

Posted by grunto - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:34 PM

@rbee90
Theres the loophole lol

http://www.g4tv.com/xplay/re views/1794/Metal_Gear_Solid_4_ Guns_of_the_Patriots.html

youll prolly have to back out the spaces in the link depending on how the message posts...

Posted by o0_Vertigo_0o - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:34 PM

WHAT!!
This is whack man this is so not cool fable wasnt that good of a game i mean not good enough to be game of the year especialy sense theres so many other games that came out
.sigh. I guess I should have expected it from those fable 2 adds on the site

Posted by volcane2004 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:36 PM

no awards for any wii title...

Posted by superdudeonfire - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:37 PM

I"m not going to say gears of war 2 should be goty, because i haven't played resistance or mgs4, but fable 2 come on. I mean every other game on the list should have beaten it in my opinion. And also how did fable 2 win goty, but fallout3 won best rpg.

Posted by o0_Vertigo_0o - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:37 PM

also
"you beter check your self before you wreck yourself"
I mean seriously G4 look at the fan boys

Posted by deleted_A6AF56F4-DA98-49AC-A673-5A686932D6E4 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:37 PM

g4 better barricade their doors,

Posted by mastercolmn - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:38 PM

im frankly pissed off and i think g4 has lost alot of its credibility here

Posted by DuskMaster22 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:39 PM

Am I the only person that remembers that like half of all Fable players are still frozen in some town thanks to a "minor" glitch?

Posted by mastercolmn - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:40 PM

im frankly pissed off and i think g4 has lost alot of its credibility here

Posted by grunto - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:41 PM

@Taarec10
Lay off the dude damn. Im tired of you talking so bad about the guy. I agree with you they made a poor choice. But damn whats done is done. And before you go bashing me for 1) ridin his sack2) me being paid off by him or 3) me being gay. Realise I too am a gamer, and have been posting on this site long enough to get a general vibe for the webmasters on here. Bleahy may be biased or he may not (says hes not) but Im not one to judge.

Just leave the dude outta this. Talk to him, but dont cuss him out every post you make. It gets really old seeing your same crap pop up over an over again on this topic. We get it you dont like Bleahy. You've made your point so just talk about sumthn else....

Posted by bleahy - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:41 PM

Taarec10 has been banned.

There's really only so much I'm willing to put up with when it comes to personal attacks, especially when they are directed at me.

Remember where you're posting.

I'm trying to keep the comments civil and focused on games, but people like Taarec10 just want to make it about hate.

That gets him a ban. Don't make the same mistakes he did.

Posted by CPRxChris - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:41 PM

@ rbee90

I didn't say anything except what I wanted to win...thats it. Chill. And I don't know, maybe Fable II did deserve it more. I haven't played Gears of War 2 or Fable II but was planning on it.

Oh and by the way, I'm a sucker for Open-sandbox games so I bought a 60GB 360 Pro for Crackdown and Saint's Row 1 (no, I'm not joking) but it RROD'd on me 30 minutes after opening it. I bought it early November and sent it in, it's been about 3 weeks or so and no response or anything yet.

...

Posted by CPRxChris - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:42 PM

...


I loved the original Fable, (I bought Fable: The Lost Chapters) but the save system killed it for me. And Gears of War, while not my main interest in the 360, I might have picked it up somewhere along the way. I still think I shouldn't have bought a 360 (considering what happened), instead waiting for the inevitable (and usually superior) PC-port. But I don't have the time nor the patience to upgrade my PC for every single game, so I bought it anyway. I joking saying "I give it a week" and I was too generous. I don't know what to do when (or at the rate of it, IF) the console comes back, probably put the refurb on eBay.

Posted by deleted_2EE6C52C-379C-4245-B72D-E38B6C785A03 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:42 PM

I told y'all g4 is fixed by microsoft!! Again just like last year!!! Fable didn't win a single award in none of theirs catogories and they win goty?? Wtf. See it's fixed and y'all know it. Just like last year! Halo 3 didn't win no awards but ended up winning goty!? Now imma stop watching g4 awards. Now that I know it's fixed. Spike awards are the real awards

Posted by targetenemy - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:43 PM

rpgs are overrated

i was hoping gears or resistance won

but fable 2?

fable2?

are you serious

not my choise,

Posted by halokiller455 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:43 PM

Fable 2 had terrible co-op, the story didn't last very long, the quests had little substance, and It had NO challenge whatsoever. Why the hell did they pick it over Fallout 3, which was much better.

Also Tales of Vesperia should have won best rpg.

Posted by theAntiFanboy - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:46 PM

@ Brian Leahy
what picks surprised you and what would you have picked for GOTY?

Posted by halokiller455 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:46 PM

Also Brian Leahy hates black people:)

Please don't ban me

Posted by CPRxChris - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:47 PM

No fanboyism in that post above, only truth.

Oh, and Bleahy, I was about to ask you if that was Taarec10 that was banned, but apparently it is. Thanks, that guy was being ridiculous. Now, are you going to start swinging the banhammer some more? Please say yes, we need more control in these "battlefields" we call forums. (Slight MGS4 reference there, lol).

Posted by bleahy - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:47 PM

@halokiller455,

Now that's just ridiculous.

Posted by bleahy - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:49 PM

Yes. The Banhammer will indeed be swung more often.

It will be reserved for personal attacks or any hate that isn't directed at GAMES.

You can get as angry as you want as long as you keep it focused on the games.

Posted by hellrazer360 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:50 PM

LOL at all the PS3 fanboys thinking metal gear solid 4 should have one...well guess what it didnt so stop thinking that G4 is biased and accept that an xbox 360 exclusive got GOTY...i know its hard but you have got to try LOL

Posted by BigBoss92 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:50 PM

well i just give up on these award shows. Did anyone at G4 play these games or what? come on MGS4 was incredible i cant even describe how amazing that game was im speechless about it. Gears 2 was also great and Fable II ? Really This right here is AN EPIC FAIL!!!

Posted by targetenemy - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:52 PM

gears and resistance didnt even get any awards now that i check

weak list

why didnt they pay attention to th poll

Posted by grunto - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:53 PM

@hellrazer360
Its not so much the fact its a 360 exclusive. Its the fact that almost no1, except a very slight few, believe Fable 2 should have won.

Posted by rbee90 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:53 PM

@brian leahy

wow! someone got banned! first time seeing that...

Posted by RedRingOfDeath (BANNED) - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:53 PM

@Brian Leahy

What about all of the hate and personal attacks directed at me?

Posted by bleahy - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:54 PM

They will be looked at.

Posted by rbee90 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:54 PM

@RROD

OMG! you just made me crap dude! LMFAO!

Posted by Donthate - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:54 PM

Leahy
I'm wondering(if you're still playing gears 2) if you ranked up to four by now. I'm getting pissed off at the rank system right now.

Posted by BobitoZ - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:54 PM

Just like the Oscars. It's all about the Money and Politics now.

X-play/G4 you have Truly become Corporate.

Posted by CPRxChris - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:55 PM

@ Bleahy

This Taarec10 situation reminds me of something:

I don't know if you fixed it or not, but I remember once when I got logged out and signed in (accidentally putting the wrong password) it said that my account was banned and it scared the crap out of me (I'm using Mozilla Firefox, if that matters), lol. I put the right password and it was fine, just giving you a heads-up though.

Posted by halokiller455 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:55 PM

Also Condemned should have won for sound Design.

Man that game was scary BECAUSE OF THE AMAZING SOUND DESIGN, X-PLAY.

With the chance of sounding like a crazed fanboy.

You suck X-play
/end rant

Posted by bleahy - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:55 PM

@Donthate,

I'm right between 3 and 4 currently.
A win puts me at 4, a loss puts me at 3.
It's kind of weird.

Posted by Donthate - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:58 PM

Leahy
I've been getting pissed considering gears 2 uses actually 50 ranks, I just love winning 7 games in a row, host quits, win another 7, and still not go up. LOL. then my friend has more losses, less wins, .9 something W/L and mine being 1.5 W/L and he's a four and I'm three. LOL

Posted by kai3950 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:58 PM

Resistance 2 and Gear of War 2 were both kick ass gmae yet neither win won award. What the hell?

Posted by bleahy - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:58 PM

@CPRxChris,

I'll have our tech guys look at the message for a wrong password. thanks.

Posted by grunto - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:58 PM

Just for future reference, to all you gamers out there. Dont post on here and play a intense game of madden at the same time X.x Doesnt end too well lol

Posted by shadowninja11 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:58 PM

I am a true fan of Xplay and will always be a fan, but honestly, when I saw the link to the video of Peter Molynexu acceptance speak, I thought it was like a joke that made him look like a loser. But, really, Fable 2! It didn't get one award! Somehow an RPG that wasn't voted "Best RPG" won, I smell a dirty bribe going on here. Should have been GTAIV, MGS 4 or GoW2

Posted by deleted_C500C119-53DD-4584-B8AF-983D528528D8 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 7:59 PM

kz2 is the best graphics on a console ever and next up gow3. the poor 3shytie has nothen to compete and the xbots still stay that microshaft has the better console when all it does is rrod.
lol i heard recently that rrod was still at 30% since nxe. funny that xbots like being screwed left and right. and now there big argument that 3fixme has better games is up they have nothen coming in 09 except halo3(dogshyt) you know that disapointing add on to an already crappy game and
what do you know halo wars a crappy rts by a crappy studio ensemble. no wonder ms is shuting them down

Posted by SkinnyJr - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:00 PM

Anything should have won over fable 2. bad choice. MGS4 gets 4 awards but not goty? okay... I think most choices were pretty lame though. I think you guys just like to piss us off lately. Ill stick to Spike TV- They'll be showing God of war 3 GAMEPLAY footage

Posted by bleahy - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:00 PM

@Donthate,

Gears 2 has 5 ranks.

Posted by o_NIGHT_TRAIN_o - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:00 PM

WTF MGS4 didnt win GOTY and best writing boy xplay screwed up. What I really find just f@#$ up is that GTA4 got best writing, like come on you can predict the whole GTA storyline without even hearing anything about it, MGS4 had such an amazing story t should have got best writing. Also how did MGS4 win 4 awards and not win GOTY and Fable 2 won ZERO awards and won GOTY, G4 should stop taking bribes.

Posted by grunto - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:01 PM

Thats true Kai. 60 player competitive and 8 player co-op(absolutely addicting, right in time for final no less) and an engaging plot is an amazing 1-2-3 knock out combo when it comes quality games.... And Horde? Aww man, dont get me started on that addiction....

Posted by listener88 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:02 PM

Fable 2 as GOTY ... no way. Just Goggle for glitches and you will see thousands of hits - the game has problems and they still aren't solved. Fall Out 3 beat it as RPG of the year and Fable 2 wins game of the year -- how does that happen - talk about biased. Must be money talking somewhere.

Posted by Donthate - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:02 PM

Leahy
I know gears 2 has 5 visable ranks, but in all has 50 non veiwable ranks in the backround. Forgot to clarify, sorry.

Posted by listener88 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:04 PM

Fable 2 as GOTY ... no way. Just Goggle for glitches and you will see thousands of hits - the game has problems and they still aren't solved. Fall Out 3 beat it as RPG of the year and Fable 2 wins game of the year -- how does that happen - talk about biased. Must be money talking somewhere.

Posted by paladin_vince - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:05 PM

no ive only played fable 2 in the local game shop...
for extended periods of time....
like halo 3...
6 hour long binges of standing in a store looking up at a screen during their slow hours of the day...

i must admit...
i kinda agree...
its a very good and unique game...
nuf said...

Posted by CPRxChris - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:05 PM

@ Bleahy

What about if we're in a bad mood about something and we say something like "G4/IGN/GameSpot/EuroGamer/1UP /etc. sucks/are biased/can't review properly/are paid off/etc." we're talking about something remotely game-related I suppose, but not directly about games...

Posted by chiuna - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:06 PM

I was glad Fable II won... I've really loved playing it. I'll agree that its weird GOTY didn't win in its own category, though. Fable 2 for best RPG as well!

Posted by listener88 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:07 PM

Fable 2 as GOTY ... no way. Just Goggle for glitches and you will see thousands of hits - the game has problems and they still aren't solved. Fall Out 3 beat it as RPG of the year and Fable 2 wins game of the year -- how does that happen - talk about biased. Must be money talking somewhere.

Posted by chaos118 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:08 PM

I serously didn't see Fable 2 winning, wtf is wrong with xplay they had so many better games to choose from. I've had Fable 2 since the day it came out and by no means does it have goty potential... I was hoping it would be Mgs4, Left4Dead, or Resistance 2 personaly. I was also disappointed that Valkyria Chronicles didn't win best strategy game, but oh well looks like xplay can't make everyone happy, so they had to do the next best thing and just piss the majority of us off.

Posted by CPRxChris - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:08 PM

@ Bleahy

No problem.

Posted by halokiller455 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:09 PM

Although the good things about Fable 2 are The dog(which I think Morgan likes), What little of the story there is is epic, not to the graphics.

That still isn't enough for game of the year.

Posted by bleahy - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:09 PM

CPRxChris,

Keep the G4 sucks stuff to a minimum. We're not banning it outright, but remember that you ARE posting on G4tv.com.

Same goes for other sites. You can discuss them, but don't be overly hateful. It's just games man, let's all just have fun.

Posted by Dudeman50114 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:09 PM

they're all good games but mgs4 should of won GOTY in my opinion

Posted by Donthate - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:10 PM

Listener88
just because you heard of one glitch does not mean there are several thousand glitches used purposely. Fable 2 was a good game, G4 will not change their opinion for you.

Posted by listener88 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:10 PM

Fable 2 as GOTY ... no way. Just Goggle for glitches and you will see thousands of hits - the game has problems and they still aren't solved. Fall Out 3 beat it as RPG of the year and Fable 2 wins game of the year -- how does that happen - talk about biased. Must be money talking somewhere.

Posted by chaos118 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:11 PM

I serously didn't see Fable 2 winning, wtf is wrong with xplay they had so many better games to choose from. I've had Fable 2 since the day it came out and by no means does it have goty potential... I was hoping it would be Mgs4, Left4Dead, or Resistance 2 personaly. I was also disappointed that Valkyria Chronicles didn't win best strategy game, but oh well looks like xplay can't make everyone happy, so they had to do the next best thing and just piss the majority of us off.

Posted by grunto - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:13 PM

Brrr.... This topics getn cold. Not too much going on any more.... seems every1 has had their say....

Posted by Donthate - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:13 PM

Listener88
please go back to the g4tv home page and stop refreshing a sentance(you're using firefox aren't you)

Posted by grunto - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:14 PM

@Donthate
He doesnt have to go all the way back to the home page. He can simply scroll to the top of this page, re-click the topic name, and it refreshes without re-posting.

Posted by o_NIGHT_TRAIN_o - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:14 PM

WTF MGS4 didnt win GOTY and best writing boy xplay screwed up. What I really find just f@#$ up is that GTA4 got best writing, like come on you can predict the whole GTA storyline without even hearing anything about it, MGS4 had such an amazing story t should have got best writing. Also how did MGS4 win 4 awards and not win GOTY and Fable 2 won ZERO awards and won GOTY, G4 should stop taking bribes.

Posted by rbee90 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:15 PM

@grunto

yep...im glad we were hee early dude...

Posted by BroodofEvil - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:18 PM

Best RPG - Fallout 3
Game of the Year - Fable II


lol wut?

Posted by grunto - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:19 PM

Well guys I am out. Its movie night on the floor and Batman came out so check you all later.... Happy Posting lol

Posted by BroodofEvil - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:23 PM

Best RPG - Fallout 3
Game of the Year - Fable II


lol wut?

Posted by captiancapybara - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:24 PM

I found it very ironic that Fable 2 won considering when G4 website polled on what the game of the year should be and Fable 2 was dead last by a considerable margin. I would have wanted the Gears of War 2 to win but to be unbiased I think GTA4 should have gotten it.

Posted by deleted_2EE6C52C-379C-4245-B72D-E38B6C785A03 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:24 PM

@hellrazer360
its not so much of an exclusive.... its going on pc so it aint an 360 exclusive


and Everyone. yeah yall know it was fixed. i see everybody agrees with that. come on fable???

Posted by whatchel - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:25 PM

Wow Fable II huh? So glad I stopped watching that joke of a show.

I think they took a page from Rod Blagojevich and sold GOTY to the highest bidder.

Posted by TheRedStar - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:28 PM

@Brian Leahy: Actually, Yes opinion does suggest Bias. Hence the Term "Bias Opinion". Grunto's right you did do a lot for MGS4. Your probably the only one on G4 who gave the game the treatment it deserved.

You Want reasons here goes....

Best RPG:::Fallout?? It's more of a shooter than traditional RPG. Fable should of at least won't in it's own category. The environment of Fallout is huge but it's story from what i here is short.

Best Writeing: GT4..it was good, but certainly not better than MGS4. From Technical knowledge to me multi-level depth MGS4 has this down pact, but that marriage sceen near the end was bizare. Perhaps Dead Space Should of won best Writeing Story seems preaty good to me.

Posted by mqlorenz - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:28 PM

Calm down fellow nerds. Maybe Xplay actually, honestly, chose the game they had the most FUN playing. Maybe not technically the best game, or the most "deep" rpg but maybe it was the one that provided the "best" time had.... I know, I know what a strange way to judge a game. Based on fun. Those guys are crazy.

/sarcasm for you idiots out there.

Posted by JOKE5TER - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:31 PM

Yeah I don't agree with Fable 2 winning GOTY. I can't remember how many hours I logged into Fable 2, but I beat it once and didn't feel like playing it again..........at least not yet. But Fallout 3, my first play through I logged in 68 hrs. Once I beat it I within a matter of days I started a new game. I logged in 62 hrs on my 2nd play through...........finally I get my moneys worth. I'm tired of waiting for hyped up games only to beat it in a matter of a day. Anways, my point is Fallout 3 diffinitly deserves GOTY.

Posted by bleahy - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:31 PM

@TheRedStar,

Close, but no. A biased opinion is an opinion based on bias.

I'm a total MGS and MGS4 fan so me choosing that as a GOTY would be a biased opinion.

Having an opinion about something is not inherently biased.

Posted by MassAffect - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:32 PM

I loved Fable 2, Gears 2, GTA IV, Fallout 3, and Resistance 2. Figured Gears 2 would take GOTY, absolutely loved it. All you self important people hatin on this website, it's really sad. If G4 pissed you off so much with their choices, go watch another show or website where their choices pandered to what you wanted to happen. Being the fanboys you are you'll be back to watch and bitch about XPlay and the G4 website.

Posted by MassAffect - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:35 PM

I loved Fable 2, Gears 2, GTA IV, Fallout 3, and Resistance 2. Figured Gears 2 would take GOTY, absolutely loved it. All you self important people hatin on this website, it's really sad. If G4 pissed you off so much with their choices, go watch another show or website where their choices pandered to what you wanted to happen. Being the fanboys you are you'll be back to watch and bitch about XPlay and the G4 website.

Posted by rickybibble - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:36 PM

@leahy

you mentioned that if you lost, you would go down in rank but if you won another round you would go up, where did you get that information. please help me out in decoding this gears 2 ranking system.

and just to add to this conversation, fable 2 doesn't seem like it deserved goty.

Posted by Draq - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:36 PM

I don't agree with Fable 2 winning. Be it that I have never played it cause I don't have a 360 but I think Fallout 3 should have gotten it. That game is AMAZING

Posted by plato2788 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:37 PM

here you have it guys 100% proof that x-play just gets paid for their opinion...
Leahy...
how does Fable 2 win GOTY, but not best RPG?? How does it win GOTY, when MGS4 won what...4 other categories??? How does the new dog character provide so much support for their decision, yet the dog, doesn't win as best new character?? And how does the Wii continue to dominate as far as popularity goes, but not one Wii game wins (most notably and ONLY one is nominated??? (Brawl, the highest selling video game this year, isn't even nominated??? wtf???)

x-play is a joke, g4 is a joke...s r e k c u f

Posted by Aztec23 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:37 PM

I haven't post because I have been to busy playing Resistance 2. R2 should have won or MGS4.

Posted by deleted_5A27CCD0-FCF9-4B3A-84B9-516286D45006 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:39 PM

wow! xplay what version did you play? i got the one with ok graphics small tight world a dog that lacked luster and a character i ended up hating because all the good and evil things are so controlled. the game basically forces you to be good unless you want to be ugly grey skined hairless ratmole freak thing. and everything makes you evil the only thing that doesn't is not playing the game. GEARS OF WAR 2 OR SOMETHING ELSE SHOULD HAVE WON YOU ONE EYED ONE HORN FLYING PURPLE PEOPLE EATERS! WOW YOU GUYS DROPPED THE BALL ON THIS ONE. I WANT A VOTE! LOOK AT THE POLL YOU TOOK YOU FREAKING DIPS!

Posted by blakseed - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:40 PM

Man. More than a few surprises there. R2 or Gears 2 didn't win anything? And Fable 2 GOTY? I think I might have to give it a shot. I was Expecting MGS4 GOTY because it won hella awards. Little Big Planet won more awards than I thought it would too.

Posted by erick81 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:42 PM

Could only convince Molyneux to come on the show. Fable didn't evan win best rpg.

Posted by Scarfaceexe - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:45 PM

Forget it, we should of known some bull like this would of happened. I mean everyone could agree that even though fable is suppose to be a good game ,its out of its league when it comes to MGS4, Fallout 3, GeOW2, or even R2. Mgs4 worked so hard to improve on every error and perfect gameplay. IT even won the most awards out of any game. IT was even out longer than Fable 2. Something tells me hype from Peter and xplay is to blame. But I digress obviously something isn't right with the system.

Posted by JOKE5TER - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:45 PM

Yeah I don't agree with Fable 2 winning GOTY. I can't remember how many hours I logged into Fable 2, but I beat it once and didn't feel like playing it again..........at least not yet. But Fallout 3, my first play through I logged in 68 hrs. Once I beat it I within a matter of days I started a new game. I logged in 62 hrs on my 2nd play through...........finally I get my moneys worth. I'm tired of waiting for hyped up games only to beat it in a matter of a day. Anways, my point is Fallout 3 diffinitly deserves GOTY.

Posted by erick81 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:45 PM

Could only convince Molyneux to come on the show. Fable didn't evan win best rpg.

Posted by kiridian - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:46 PM

WHAT!? Fable 2!? GOTY!? Ok for real wtf, the game was alright but GOTY jesus fallout 3 was a much much much better game then fable 2 or MGS4 hell i would have rather seen Gears of war 2 (highly over rated game if you ask me) win GOTY. Come on guys i know peter was visiting the show but selling out is just wrong to the fans man. Man thats just wrong

Posted by halokiller455 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:50 PM

Maybe X-play gave it to Fable 2 just so Peter could announce new games.

Posted by RedRingofDouche - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:50 PM

fable 2 didn't deserve GOTY. but what im mad about is how the hell did L4D win best shooter?!?! there were so many better choices

Posted by TheRedStar - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:51 PM

Most Original::: Braid?? Why not LBP? I'm confused....I've never played a game where the game play was the actual driveing point of the game, and then you get an indepth level design that you can play w/ friends and let literaly hundreds of others play. Where has that been done before?

Best Multi-Player:::Left4Dead??? I haven't heard 1 person speak well of their MultiPlayer. Call of Duty...even though not that different in feal from COD4 it's still good. Resistance2's CoOp is crazy good and fits the story.

Best MMO:::WarHammer?? Why isn't WoW crack? or does it not count beacuse it's only had expansions?

Best Animation:::Why Not Gears or MGS4 both were visually stunning. Or Dead Space...Moveing parts that don't stop till you blow of their lims...that alone gets it for me

--Why aren't any Wii games up there? Smash Brothers was a good game.

Posted by Goatslayer72 (BANNED) - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:51 PM

So Sony got 6, Xbox got 5, Multi-Plat. got 7, DS got 1, and PC got 2...Fable wtf?!?!

Posted by gravy666 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:54 PM

G4 viewers have good taste. The games that won awards deserved them. But I'm still disappointed about that Mirror's Edge thing...

Posted by kiridian - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:55 PM

WHAT!? Fable 2!? GOTY!? Ok for real wtf, the game was alright but GOTY jesus fallout 3 was a much much much better game then fable 2 or MGS4 hell i would have rather seen Gears of war 2 (highly over rated game if you ask me) win GOTY. Come on guys i know peter was visiting the show but selling out is just wrong to the fans man. Man thats just wrong

Posted by Sketch243 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:55 PM

Yeah!! Fable 2
for me it was either Fable 2 or GTA 4, I could replay those games over and over, but Gears 2 basically Gears 1, MGS4 imo boring, fallout 3 been there done that

Posted by JOKE5TER - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:59 PM

Yeah I don't agree with Fable 2 winning GOTY. I can't remember how many hours I logged into Fable 2, but I beat it once and didn't feel like playing it again..........at least not yet. But Fallout 3, my first play through I logged in 68 hrs. Once I beat it I within a matter of days I started a new game. I logged in 62 hrs on my 2nd play through...........finally I get my moneys worth. I'm tired of waiting for hyped up games only to beat it in a matter of a day. Anways, my point is Fallout 3 diffinitly deserves GOTY.

Posted by blakseed - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 8:59 PM

Dead Space should have been nominated more. That game surprised the hell out of me.

Posted by kiridian - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 9:00 PM

WHAT!? Fable 2!? GOTY!? Ok for real wtf, the game was alright but GOTY jesus fallout 3 was a much much much better game then fable 2 or MGS4 hell i would have rather seen Gears of war 2 (highly over rated game if you ask me) win GOTY. Come on guys i know peter was visiting the show but selling out is just wrong to the fans man. Man thats just wrong

Posted by Goatslayer72 (BANNED) - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 9:03 PM

all you little flamers are so cute gettin' your panties all in a twist and resorting to conspiracy theories, shoot im still playing Oblivion, once im done, imunna hop on Fallout Tres', luh you guys like a fat kid luh cake;)

Posted by sneakers_otool - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 9:08 PM

first congrats i guess r in order for fable i kind wish gears would have one best multiplayer or somting and gears or resistance for GoTY

Posted by TheRedStar - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 9:12 PM

@Brian Leahy: Your completely right, but that's why i said "...suggest...". Unfortunately you and your buddies at G4 for the most part have negative (Bias) opinions of virtually anything PS3 related. To be honest your wonderfull and detailed insight to MGS4 was absolutely bizzzzar and uncharacteristic of G4, But it was GREAT! It was probably the best reporting done on this site all year. It was all about the game.

-On a side a side note it's good to see that Shooters are not the only thing being played...for a second there I almost thought the whole world had gone shooter.

Posted by prodigykidd - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 9:16 PM

Thats insanity man. Fable2 doesnt deserve GoTY. I would have rather seen an over rated game like Gears2 be GoTY then Fable. MGS4 all the way. Also, the best shooter and best multiplayer is horrible as well. Everything else was good though.

Posted by adam_sessler - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 9:19 PM

Hello everyone, it's the actual Adam Sessler here. It would appear that this year, as in all past, we've managed to elucidate some...strong reactions. I thought I'd weigh in with some thoughts.

1) As Editor-in-Chief, I take ultimate responsibility for the decisions made in these awards. Let's funnel the blame in my direction, you know I'm used to it.

2) It would be naive to assume that we didn't anticipate a lot of backlash in our decisions, especially for GOTY. Nonetheless, we make our determinations independent of the internet mob.

3) The X-Play GOTY awards are not intended to validate the opinions of others, it is intended to bring notice to achievements we find worthy of special commendation. Your opinions are your own, we think nothing less of them.

All together now.....

chill.

Posted by Goatslayer72 (BANNED) - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 9:25 PM

I hope that Sesslar does a Soapbox about this, ive been reading all of these post and, WOW, this is WAY out of hand, chill, I think that Katamari Damacy should have won GOTY, but thats cuz im trapped in the past, its ok to disagree but these verbal rampages are uncouth...what would your mother's think about your potty mouth rampages?

Posted by newbman - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 9:26 PM

I love how everyone says they hate g4, but they are commenting on it.

And Fable 2... what?

Posted by ZombiesRPplsToo - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 9:27 PM

fable deserved that award, fallout was amazing but it just was too bleak a game for me (i know its supposed to be)

Posted by Goatslayer72 (BANNED) - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 9:30 PM

@adam_sessler

sorry about spelling your last name wrong, you'd think I would know how to spell it considering how often I watch X-Play, good show tonight, even though I still think Katamari should've won!

Posted by Goatslayer72 (BANNED) - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 9:31 PM

@adam_sessler

sorry about spelling your last name wrong, you'd think I would know how to spell it considering how often I watch X-Play, good show tonight, even though I still think Katamari should've won!

Posted by ZombiesRPplsToo - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 9:31 PM

out of every nomination i agreed with all but one (which im not surprised i tend to agree with xplay) which was MULTIPLAYER: resistance 2 deserved that one

Posted by LeonBlade - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 9:34 PM

I don't believe that's the real Adam...

Never the less... Fable 2 winning GOTY is a HUGE fail...
It didn't even win Best RPG, yet won the GOTY? That makes no sense what so ever... Also, MGS4 won 4 awards... more than any other title... LBP wasn't even in the GOTY catagory which is stupid...

But I know why MGS4 didn't win... when it should of...
Because X-Play, as well as the rest of G4, are Xbots... Xbox Fanboys...

They have Xbox 360 controllers in all of their animations for their ads and what not... X-Play always reviews the Xbox version of a multiplatform game... It's complete bull crap...

GOTY was an epic fail... and when Xbox fans and PS3 fans agree on something like this... you know that it's serious... Because that NEVER happens...

Posted by deleted_C7D2E261-C77D-4DB7-8461-CE9C18D86FF6 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 9:35 PM

Wow I really enjoyed Fable 2 but Fallout 3 blew me away like no other game. O well at least RROD can suck it.

Posted by LeonBlade - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 9:38 PM

I don't believe that's the real Adam...

Never the less... Fable 2 winning GOTY is a HUGE fail...
It didn't even win Best RPG, yet won the GOTY? That makes no sense what so ever... Also, MGS4 won 4 awards... more than any other title... LBP wasn't even in the GOTY catagory which is stupid...

But I know why MGS4 didn't win... when it should of...
Because X-Play, as well as the rest of G4, are Xbots... Xbox Fanboys...

They have Xbox 360 controllers in all of their animations for their ads and what not... X-Play always reviews the Xbox version of a multiplatform game... It's complete bull crap...

GOTY was an epic fail... and when Xbox fans and PS3 fans agree on something like this... you know that it's serious... Because that NEVER happens...

Posted by LeonBlade - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 9:40 PM

WTF? Double post...

Posted by garrettkers - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 9:46 PM

My thinking Brain Hurts from the confusion

Posted by plato2788 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 9:46 PM

here you have it guys 100% proof that x-play just gets paid for their opinion...
Leahy...
how does Fable 2 win GOTY, but not best RPG?? How does it win GOTY, when MGS4 won what...4 other categories??? How does the new dog character provide so much support for their decision, yet the dog, doesn't win as best new character?? And how does the Wii continue to dominate as far as popularity goes, but not one Wii game wins (most notably and ONLY one is nominated??? (Brawl, the highest selling video game this year, isn't even nominated??? wtf???)

x-play is a joke, g4 is a joke...s r e k c u f

Posted by mqlorenz - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 10:03 PM

Calm down fellow nerds. Maybe Xplay actually, honestly, chose the game they had the most FUN playing. Maybe not technically the best game, or the most "deep" rpg but maybe it was the one that provided the "best" time had.... I know, I know what a strange way to judge a game. Based on fun. Those guys are crazy.

/sarcasm for you idiots out there.

Posted by mybum - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 10:06 PM

i gotta admit, i didnt like fable2 as much because it focuses so much on the sidequests...
gears of war2 not the best multiplayer? thats insane.
left4 dead is awesome though...
best action:mgs4? thats the most outrageous thing on here, mgs4 was full of cutscenes....
o well, more 360 exclusives won the awards....
ps3 sucks!!!LOL

Posted by mybum - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 10:10 PM

sony should bring back ps2 games on ps3....that would increase the chance of ps3 game winning the goty by 10%!
o wait, ps3 cant even play ps2 games now, lol
in other words, ps3 is not powerful enough to play ps2 games
HAHAHAHAHA

Posted by John1337 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 10:12 PM

Damn this award shoulda went to mgs4, sure fable 2 was good at most, mgs4 blew your mind, great plot, fun to play, great music, sounds, and multiplayer. sigh... well at least it got like 4 awards...
shoulda got goty

Posted by bradt44 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 10:17 PM

I hope they actually check this board and realize that everyone thinks that there awards were complete bull..like fable 2 shouldnt been anywhere near goty, and anyone who played fallout3, gears 2, mgs4 would know. I think fallout should have win but the fact that fable was even nominated let alone win is crazy..I think im done trusting any of their judgments!

Posted by ProjektX13 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 10:20 PM

i love my xbox exclusives but come on FABLE? i would have rather MGS4 win than fable!!!

Posted by theg3neral - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 10:21 PM

Midnight Club: Los Angeles should've got Best Racing Game.

Posted by bigpamurf - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 10:41 PM

Everyone talks of how fable dont deserve it and how Fallout or MSG4 deserved it but thats BS. GTA 4 should've robbed this awards. Niko Bellic is the most complex video game character to date and they give it to a character from the videogame equivalent of Young and the restless. Fallout 3 although good still nowhere near as fun as GTA 4. As Gears of War 2 was a throwaway single player game. Multiplayer should have gonne to gears for the horde mode alone, one of the best modes around. As for action games seriousy MSG 4 doesn't compare to what was done with GTA 4. WHere MSG 4 improved its controls over a reletivley lengthy period of time and is not as dramatic, GTA 4 fixed every control issue it had been blamed of in the past drastically improving the gameplay. GTA4 is the interactive work of art unparrealled this year and its sad to see that it lost to games all drastically inferior to it.

Posted by lyoko2 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 10:50 PM

@adam_sessler ZOMG IT yu i am not worthy, i am not worthy but all say i think you guys made i good chioce.why becuose games that break the buondrys should get a game award even game of the year(like bioshock for exsample) who could have been the plain black and white shooter but decide to turn in a different direction of the common fps.mgs 4 was great but it lacked new ideas which i see why you picked fable 2 it improved greatly from the first fable and felt like you actuly had a choice plus no fence boundrys lol

Posted by JDarkley - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 10:52 PM

Before anybody else posts, read Sessler's post above.
For the record, GTA IV was my pick for GOTY, but it's just an award show people. Chill.

Posted by K_R_Decade - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 10:53 PM

I'm glad that Braid won some awards, but I'm sad that Mirror's Edge didn't get any.

Posted by bradt44 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 11:10 PM

I hope they actually check this board and realize that everyone thinks that there awards were complete bull..like fable 2 shouldnt been anywhere near goty, and anyone who played fallout3, gears 2, mgs4 would know. I think fallout should have win but the fact that fable was even nominated let alone win is crazy..I think im done trusting any of their judgments!

Posted by Famous531 - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 11:16 PM

Yawn... Fable 2?

I was thinking either MGS4 or Fallout 3..

ooh well.

Posted by Ieyke - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 11:22 PM

I'd say while Fable 2 is sort of an unexpected choice for GOTY overall most of the awards are pretty well thought out.

I dunno what the hell Braid is and why it would win most original, or how it beat Megaman 9 for Downloadable, but I can't demand a recount out of total obliviousness.

I'm sort of baffled as to how any sports game won Animation. I mean yea, that's basically all those games have going for them, but MGS4 did it ridiculously well. I guess it won enough tho :P

Many kudos to recognizing WAR as Best MMO rather than more mindless WoW fanboyism.

Sort of confused as to why LBP won the Best Gameplay Innovation....it's only the most elaborate level creator....not really something new.... *shrug*

Posted by grunto - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 11:43 PM

Hmmm.... seems things heated up while I was away. And for a while I actually thought this topic was dead. Oh well....

It appears Adam made a post. I would like to believe its really him. But for however long I have been posting I have never seen him post. This could be that I dont read all topics unless they are game related or particularly peek my interest. I do however have strong doubts that that was really him. But, based on the way many of us were bashing the daylights out of G4 (me included for a bit), and even Bleahy as a person. I wouldnt doubt it if he did actually make a post in an attempt to put out some fires. I guess I will never know (or we) if that was really Adam Sessler.

IT WOULD TOTALLY BE BADASS IF IT WAS THOUGH!!!

Posted by x_nation - Tuesday, December 9, 2008 11:44 PM

I had to post, WOW simply WOW... a GOTY has been chosen and all the fanboys come out swinging... I mean come on SERIOUSLY!!!... Are all you guys really fighting about which game got GOTY?! I may not agree with the decision either but I haven't gotten the chance to play the game as well... It is funny at how people come on to this site to state comments about certain things, and at times being very passionate about ones views, but immediately bashing or attacking the network for making their decisions is pretty childish, there are better ways to get your point across... You guys even got The SESS to come out (if it's really him)... I mean it's sorta funny but also serious... can you guys see at how you guys took all this seriously? It is just an award show about games... just enjoy playing them and move on... Stop acting like your dog just got shot and relax people...

Posted by mudearies - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 12:03 AM

Fallout3 blows Fable 2 out of the water.

Posted by EJ_Texas_Made - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 12:28 AM

What the hell? Is the guy who wrote this blog drunk or are they serious? I'm all for 360, but this is just retarded. How did a game that didn't even really deserve to be nominated (neither did L4D, though.. but both good games) end up winning the award? How much is Molyneux paying you clowns?

This list loses all credability now.. as if it had any before.

Posted by olympicheropaul - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 12:33 AM

I have no problem with Fable 2 winning. I love the game myself. I am suprised though. I thought for sure GTA 4, MGS, Gears, or Fallout would get it. Oh well, glad to be wrong. Most people will not like this decision but I give the folks at X-Play credit. They don't seem to care if they march in line with everyone else. Good for them.

Posted by EJ_Texas_Made - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 12:38 AM

@ olympicheropaul

Marching to your own drum is fine.. but normally you might have a couple people who agree with you. When all review sites disagree with you, all sales numbers disagree with you and you actually see all the Xbox 360 fans and PS3 fans on THIS SITE come together and disagree with you (which NEVER happens).. at some point you gotta wake up and realize maybe you just don't know what you're doing.

Posted by Neo2K - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 12:45 AM

@Brian Leahy
You guys should also consider dropping the ban hammer on the fanboys with comments that provoke others to the personal attacks.

I mean take a look at the idiotic comments from this kid "mybum":
"best action:mgs4? thats the most outrageous thing on here, mgs4 was full of cutscenes...."

That wasn't so provoking as it's just his opinion, but then he goes on to say:
"o well, more 360 exclusives won the awards....
ps3 sucks!!!LOL"

I'm hoping the kid is 11 years old which would make his comments understandable and forgivable, but is this the type of gaming discussion you want on these forums? Some of these kids post the same idiotic nonsense over and over with no reason or substance to back it up.

The realistic and sad part is I know he and his kind won't be banned because then you'd probably have to ban more than half of the people who post here.

Posted by Neo2K - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 12:46 AM

On topic:
Fable 2 for GOTY was a surprise. I imagined GTAIV, Fallout 3 or MGS4 taking the GOTY award.

Best new character was also a strange pick in my opinion. Drebin's hairless monkey was more memorable than him. I would have chosen Niko, or even one of his supporting characters like Brucie or even Roman.

Posted by SUICIDE_STEVE - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 1:10 AM

IMAGINE IF G4 WASN'T OWNED BY MICROSOFT.........

Posted by random_luigi07 - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 1:36 AM

I disagree with Goty MGS4 should have won close second definitely Fallout 3, I didnt like Gears 2 too much, and Resistance is fun but not a level with MGS4. Fable 2???????? Come on now I havent played the game but I know Fallout 3 has got to be better then that game.

Posted by treereet - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 1:56 AM

Hello? Burnout Paradise? Racing game of the year? How was this not chosen?

I would probably put Fable 2 in my top 10 but personally I would have picked either Fallout 3 or MGS4, it's a tossup.

Posted by ell_ess_free - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 2:33 AM

I hate to say it but I think the only reason Fable 2 secured GOTY is because its the type of game the Sess really enjoys. Although it's def in my top 10 this year maybe top 5 so many good ones though freakn Dead Space didn't even get nominated for anything and shiet

Posted by IBloodstormI - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 2:43 AM

i like fable 2 but in no way is it close to being game of the year and gears 2 not winning a single category, bull crap on all levels. goty should have at least went to fallout 3 if not gears 2 but come on. how did fable 2 win goty?

Posted by GOBBLOXX - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 3:10 AM

I don't see how a game that wasn't even good enough to win best RPG wins GOTY, wtf!!!!!!

Posted by johnny126 - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 3:33 AM

I just remembered, seeing as how people were talking about it. Back in 2004 the same thing happened with Halo 2 and Half Life 2. Half Life 2 beat out Halo 2 in best shooter, yet Halo went on to win Game of the Year.

Oh well just throwing that out there, anyway I like and fully agree with all these choices, I'm not at all disappointed, just surprised, I thought it would go to MGS4, but I got it all so I'm happy anyway.

Posted by 360guru - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 3:40 AM

@adam_sessler
Forgive me for posting so late....but I just found out the results(pls just humour me), and g4 & x-play, I'm afraid I have to agree with almost everyone or everyone entirely, FABLE 2 as GOTY, come on....

i have no grudge against anyone who made the GOTY decision but in my humble opinion,GOW2 should have won or at least either Fallout 3,MGS4 or GTA4

I mean GOW2 has jaw dropping graphics, non-repetitive combat and excellent voice acting.Let's face it,GOW2,MSG4,Fallout3 & GTA4 sold more copies than Fable 2 and they also received better criticism ,so naming Fable2 as GOTY is technically that it is better than all the other mentioned games.

Therefore pls,just for some peace of mind,give one acceptable reason the GOTY desision makers(including you) has inflicted this catastrophe upon the world(and don't give that dog companion crap)

P.S: Sorry if my message is too long,I don't do this often...oh yeah and by the way,I rooted for BIOSHOCK last year.....yay!!!!

Posted by gspider - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 3:48 AM

What fable 2 ? the game dont have even 5 stars on the show, sorry I like the show and all , but I think game of the year should be the one who have 5 stars , maybe Gears of War 2, or Metal Gear Solid 4, or GTA4, Left for dead is another good game, sorry i have Fable 2 is agood game but is not a game of the year.

Posted by sean_sobes - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 3:51 AM

fable 2=fail.
i will never watch xplay again.
aots ftw

Posted by kevamaral11688 - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 3:53 AM

as i saw it...
goty: mgs4, gta IV, gow 2.

fable was good, was good at best. i was EXTREMELY disapointed. 10 hrs go by i beat the game. then wat? we waited for wat, 2 years for a dog and 10 more hrs of gameplay? after ur done theres nuthing else to do.

resistance 2 wasnt as good as they said. i was consistanly dying cuz of stupid glitchs. and after all that i beat the game in little under 9 hrs. 1 was better in my opinion. and the ending sucked anyway.

and im an xbox fanboy and i think mgs4 was amazing.

i only started playing fallout 3 so i dont currently have an obvious opinion.

xplay is fail im srry.

Posted by kevamaral11688 - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 3:55 AM

also forgot to add.... ok yeah they sold good the first few weeks, yet u give warhammer mmo of the year?

even with reports that most of their players are coming back to wow? are you nuts? i wasted 50 bucks on warhammer to only quit a few weeks later. it soooo didnt feel right.

wow: wotlk shoulda won.

Posted by NewsTeamAssemble - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 4:11 AM

Wait a minute, a game thats not a first person shooter won? What about the many beautiful shades of gun metal grey in those games and the linear story, dont they count for any thing? Wow can you trust reliable sources any more?

Posted by brokeheart - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 5:10 AM

Wow, fable II is better than mgs4. I geuss I'm glad that I have a X-Box 360 and not a ps3 right?



WRONG!

I want mgs4! I can't afford a ps3 but I still want it.

Posted by Thundercracker - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 5:12 AM

I HATE THAT I WORK GRAVEYARD...i miss all the fun

yeah i believe that was in fact adam sessler, because first off it sounded like his speaking style and second because he didnt lower himself to responding to anyones comments

@leahy

why would someone attack YOU for this? this wasnt your choice, i think we all know that you didnt vote for fable. but i havent played the damn thing so maybe it is goty, who knows? Its not better than fallout though...

Posted by G4maniac14 - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 5:48 AM

holy CRAP that's a lot of comments...ye Fable II sucks...MGS4 should of gotten GOTY..adam sessler you're an idiot..a morgan web, we all know you DON'T play VGs...you just read from a script...

Posted by mrbeer64 - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 6:25 AM

at first i wanted to be surprised but given fable ii's advertising dollars on here - anyone remember the special background? - the repeated interviews and appearances by molyneux and his availability to accept the award (anyone really think hideo kojima would have come on?) and it becomes a little obvious why fable ii was able to win game of the year without being able to even win best rpg.

Posted by Detoxification - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 6:37 AM

I'm really confused...

Not at the fact that Fable II won game of the year, but why it really matters all that much. So YOUR favorite game or choice for game of the year doesn't have an artificial title, that means that everyone else has an invalid opinion? It's just stupid that everyone cares so much about something so stupid. Are Fallout 3, MGS4, GTA any worse for not winning? Does this destroy their credibility as meaningful games? No. And the whole argument about their being biased is just idiotic. OF COURSE THEIR IS GOING TO BE SOME TYPE OF BIAS, IT'S A GROUP OF PEOPLE'S OPINION. What were you expecting, a computer analysis of the winner?

Posted by Detoxification - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 6:38 AM

I'm really confused...

Not at the fact that Fable II won game of the year, but why it really matters all that much. So YOUR favorite game or choice for game of the year doesn't have an artificial title, that means that everyone else has an invalid opinion? It's just stupid that everyone cares so much about something so stupid. Are Fallout 3, MGS4, GTA any worse for not winning? Does this destroy their credibility as meaningful games? No. And the whole argument about their being biased is just idiotic. OF COURSE THEIR IS GOING TO BE SOME TYPE OF BIAS, IT'S A GROUP OF PEOPLE'S OPINION. What were you expecting, a computer analysis of the winner?

Posted by Detoxification - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 6:41 AM

I'm really confused...

Not at the fact that Fable II won game of the year, but why it really matters all that much. So YOUR favorite game or choice for game of the year doesn't have an artificial title, that means that everyone else has an invalid opinion? It's just stupid that everyone cares so much about something so stupid. Are Fallout 3, MGS4, GTA any worse for not winning? Does this destroy their credibility as meaningful games? No. And the whole argument about their being biased is just idiotic. OF COURSE THEIR IS GOING TO BE SOME TYPE OF BIAS, IT'S A GROUP OF PEOPLE'S OPINION. What were you expecting, a computer analysis of the winner?

Posted by gspider - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 6:41 AM

Fable 2 is a good game but not a game of the Year , Maybe Call Of duty , or left for dead or Metal gear solid 4, or maybe GTA4 with all the gliches can be GOTY, fable 2 is fun but even xplay didn't give 5 stars to the game , and for the firts time I see Xbox fan boys and Ps3 fan boys agree that is was a stupid chice,and is really funny, hey maybe the guy from Fable 2 pay some money to xplay, if that is the case , we can not trust xplay anymore, bcause they dont say the true about what is a good game a what is not a good game, I think xplay have to do the GOTY base on the gamers all of us, even on the Feed pool Fable got 12.4%, and Gears of war and fallout got 35% and 37% xplay sorry guys but this is not good for you

Posted by balmung13 - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 6:43 AM

ok these awards are crap, half of these games shouldnt have gotten the awards, i know mgs4 should have gotten there awards, but almost all the others shocked me, i mean come on fable 2, the game was so short and the quality wasnt that great i mean i played and beat it while doing all missions in under 8 hours

Posted by Detoxification - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 6:44 AM

I'm really confused...

Not at the fact that Fable II won game of the year, but why it really matters all that much. So YOUR favorite game or choice for game of the year doesn't have an artificial title, that means that everyone else has an invalid opinion? It's just stupid that everyone cares so much about something so stupid. Are Fallout 3, MGS4, GTA any worse for not winning? Does this destroy their credibility as meaningful games? No. And the whole argument about their being biased is just idiotic. OF COURSE THEIR IS GOING TO BE SOME TYPE OF BIAS, IT'S A GROUP OF PEOPLE'S OPINION. What were you expecting, a computer analysis of the winner?

Posted by Sandrock323 - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 6:45 AM

I can see why Fable would get pick as GOTY. Out of all the nominees, Fable is the only one that delivered a new innovative game. MGS4, Gears2, R2, and Fallout 3 are all remakes of previous games. Where as Fable 2 is completely different from its predecessor. It is also the only game that I can think of that is actually appealing to nongamers. ( I'm talking about real games not minigames, ie Wii Sports doesn't count)

Posted by gspider - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 6:47 AM

LOl jajaja Detoxification is really Adam from xplay, it matters because some people wach the show to see wich of the new games are good or not, a lot of people wach the show, and Fable 2 is a good game but there is a lot of better games out there that can be GOTY, now looks like Xplay chose Fable 2, why they did that?, maybe is money around this, and then the question, Should we trust xplay for reviews?, believe I like Xplay and the shows on G4 they are awesome, but we fallow this show to see wich games we can buy, we believe xplay , but we are disapointed with the GOTY thing

Posted by gspider - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 6:54 AM

I wach this show for a few years already, and is funny how from all this wonderful games this year they chose the one that do not have five stars on xplay, and a think a lot of peolpe here think the same way, i have fable 2 is really nice but I finish the game and thats it, I think the game of the year is betewn Gears of War 2, Metal gear solid 4, and Call of Dutty 4, resistance 2 have gliches and fable 2 is to short with gliches, and left for dead is awesome , but no better than Gears of war and metal gear

Posted by Detoxification - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 6:56 AM

@gspider

Oh I completely understand now. You follow everything that Adam and Morgan say, and only the games that they deem worthy are the ones that you buy. So since neither Fallout, GTA, nor MGS4 won game of the year, you all will probably not buy them, right?

But wait, it seems as though most people on here already own them. Not only that, but they think they are good. How is this possible? None of them won game of the year. That means you would have had to have relied on your own conscious and free will to form opinions on these games. Is there a new trend forming in the gaming world, a trend of free thought?

Posted by DamienHell - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 6:58 AM

I love how many people are claiming this is a conspiracy, go back to your spaceships the government is planning 9/11 again.

Posted by Detoxification - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 6:59 AM

I'm sorry, I just fail to grasp all this unnecessary bickering over this. I could understand if some indie developer with no money made an incredible game and it wasn't even talked about because of all these big named company games, but most of these games have already made billions of dollars from sales. So what is the point in defending a game from a company that isn't going to loose anything from not winning this Oh so coveted title?

Posted by mrbeer64 - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 7:01 AM

@damien

i don't think there's a conspiracy... i think that molyneux is a friend of the show and it showed.

Posted by xBlaCkBiRdx02 - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 7:04 AM

I think G4 should have switched around Fallout 3 and Fable 2..

Best RPG: Fable 2
GOTY: Fallout 3

Posted by gspider - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 7:11 AM

@Detoxification I have those games, Is just funny how they chose fable 2, I have Fable 2 is good, but not that good, I wahc the show almost every day , bcause they talk about the games I like so far, but why they chose fable 2, is not the best game, I believe this show is awesome and is one of the few, maybe the only one who talk about all games, but if they going to start doing thinks like this maybe the show is not good anymore, maybe the chose Fable 2 for money, i dont think they going to do the GOTY 08 again and if they talk about it is going to be a little, All I know is something smell weird.

Posted by gspider - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 7:17 AM

@Detoxification , i have all systems and my best games are Gta4 , maybe the game have some gliches but is awesome, Metal gear solid 4, is amazing, Gears of war 2, OMG, Resistnace is cool Online, Left for Dead is really nice kill sombies,( Is really hard) is a fantastic game, Little big planet is fun to play, Fable 2 is just ok, I think Fallout is better, and WOW is nice,

Posted by PurpleMongooseNinja - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 7:22 AM

wow...super bs, fable isn't that good. there were tons of other good games out this year. i mean really...i own fable 2 and i think it's a clone of the first one! gears2 mgs4 or resistance2 should have won.
but drebin won best original character?!?! i could've sworn that sackboy would've won. i mean come one he's a black man with white hair...just look at dennis rodman! he's not original at all!!!!!
but whatever...hopefully next year the game that deserves it will get it...i'm pullin for killzone2 right now...or maybe god of war 3?!

Posted by Detoxification - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 7:23 AM

@gspider

Mine would probably be Gears 2 or Left 4 Dead. L4D is so much fun and Gears 2 is just epic. But I really enjoyed Fable II. I hated the first one but this one was much better. I don't know. I was a bit surprised that it won too but I wouldn't say it's completely undeserving considering how much depth it has and how much it draws you into it. When I saw the list of nominees, I was thinking it would be a tough choice either way and I thought any of those games deserved it.

Posted by gspider - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 7:29 AM

@Detoxification , yeap the game is good even I was thinking to download Fable 1 on my xbox just to play it for fun, but like you know there is a lot of better games with more graphics and awesome gameplay, I like gears of War 2, I love Resident evil franchise, thats why I got L4D is awesome, I love Metal gear is amazing, this games can be game of the year is not a Big deal that the chose Fable 2, but I just want to know why thay did that, and I see all this coments and I see that im not the only one wiht questions jajajajajajjajaja

Posted by Ulrichgaming - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 7:33 AM

once again X-play showing how worthless it is... they contradict themselves in their own reward show... it's easy... they are either paid off... or just complete idiots.... I'd say complete idiots... thus why the most idiotic gamers believe and quote everything they say.... same people that think wrestling is real.

Posted by Smartguy81 - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 7:38 AM

@Thundercracker
If you haven't played Fable2 then you can't say Fallout is better than it. I own both of them. Fable2 in my opinion is alot more fun. Fallout while a good idea, needs to have issues tweaked.

Posted by gspider - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 7:38 AM

jajajaaj lol wrestling = xplay jajajajaj
I use to believe in wrestling and santa clous, xplay and farie tales,
I wonder if Adam is reading all this, jajaja so many negative comments, maybe he is going to say the samething that he say with Final Fantasy 7 for the PSP, when he saw that it was the only show that give the game a bad review, and when people didnt like what review he give the game at all

Posted by deleted_9F661924-24C1-482C-B150-6F4735B73C0F - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 7:39 AM

HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA SUCK IT FANBOYS LOL

Posted by gspider - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 7:41 AM

This should be a Epic Fail on Atack of the show that will be really funny, jajajajajajajajajajaj

Posted by gspider - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 7:43 AM

Im a Ps3XboxwiiPC fan boy who want to see in the loop on atack of the show talk about this to see whats going on with xplay

Posted by oia2 - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 7:54 AM

@mybum
PS3 exclusives won 6 awards
360 exclusives won 3 awards
360 sucks!!!
LOL!

Posted by mrbeer64 - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 8:29 AM

not that i expect xplay to go back on their choice, but i do think you'd be doing yourselves and your audience a favor if you could at least explain some of the reasoning behind picking a game that did not even win best in its genre for game of the year

Posted by MrKrinklez - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 8:30 AM

I really don't understand what all the fuss was about. I own both consoles and I still believe Fable 2 was truly a good contender for the game of the year title. Obviously either many of you can't recognize what a great game is (on a professional level), just plain have never played the game, or are a PS3 exclusive owner with pointless bias.

Posted by MrKrinklez - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 8:32 AM

@Ulrichgaming

"Most 2 faced host:
X-play (Sessler) while the Dev is on the show he's really into the game, once the review comes out they tear it down."

That would be because when the Dev is on the show, the game isn't released yet, and probably only a demo is available.
When the game comes out and the Dev was wrong about how great his game was, Adam smash.

Posted by MrKrinklez - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 8:34 AM

@gspider

fail

Posted by mikemill - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 8:37 AM

LMFAO at X Play goes crazy in the head yet again. Fable 2 is game of the year??? LMAO!!! Fable 2 doesn't even win best game in it's own genre with you guys, but it wins GOTY???? LMAO!!!! No way that Fable 2 was a better, bigger game than GTA 4 or MGS4, or Gears 2. X Play, your credibility gets weaker and weaker by the day. I only check in to see news updates now... your review and game analysis credibility has become a TOTAL JOKE.

Posted by JDarkley - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 8:40 AM

My God folks, everybody is acting like G4 raped their mother. I don't think that Fable II was GOTY either, but good lord. You people are taking this way too seriously. Everybody just shut the kcuf up and chill.

Posted by gspider - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 8:43 AM

jajaja maybe xplay want to put wii music as a game of the year lol

Posted by gspider - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 8:44 AM

jajaja maybe xplay want to put wii music as a game of the year lol

Posted by Trieloth - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 8:59 AM

Fable 2 GOTY? Ahh hell NO!! That game was ass.

Posted by gspider - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 9:05 AM

I will hate to be Adam right know and walk on the streets and little kids calling me names and all the hard core gamers telling me how much money I got from the Fable 2 producer lol

Posted by gspider - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 9:09 AM

Adam and Morgan you guys going to have a nice Chrismas with the money you guys got ajajajaj

Posted by bigmonstefan - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 9:14 AM

I was actually very disappointed with fable 2. It was fun for about 8 hours, but when everything is so freaking easy to kill, and just easy to do in general, it just gets boring. Oh well, happy holidays to the G4, even if I do disagree.

Posted by Thundercracker - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 9:19 AM

@smartguy

while technically you are correct, being wrong has never stopped me before. So i stick by my story sampson simpson


it would have to kick major ass to be better than resistance, gears or fallout....thats what i should have said huh?

abracadabra

Posted by Ghostman2k78 - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 9:19 AM

Congrats Fable! I was pleasantly surprised to find out that Gears2 didn't win- hooray for the underdog!

Posted by Bookshelf - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 9:20 AM

MGS4 mentioned 4 times and Gears 2 not mentioned once? coulda fooled me.

Posted by GamersVoiceOfReason - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 9:20 AM

Before I hand down my gauntlet of reason, I will gladly admit that Fable II was a very good game. It could have easily won GOTY any other year.....except this one.

I noticed that Adam Sessler himself has tried to defend X-Play's decision on these awards by aiming the blame towards him. I'm going to respectfully disagree point by point:

"It would appear that this year, as in all past, we've managed to elucidate some...strong reactions. It would be naive to assume that we didn't anticipate a lot of backlash in our decisions, especially for GOTY. Nonetheless, we make our determinations independent of the internet mob. "

Adam, in case you forgot, these were G4's last three GOTY winners....Bioshock, Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess, Resident Evil 4. Weeding out fanboy opinions, I think most of us would agree here that G4's Fable II decision would be a little less believable out of these 4 GOTY winners.

Posted by GamersVoiceOfReason - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 9:21 AM

Before I hand down my gauntlet of reason, I will gladly admit that Fable II was a very good game. It could have easily won GOTY any other year.....except this one.

I noticed that Adam Sessler himself has tried to defend X-Play's decision on these awards by aiming the blame towards him. I'm going to respectfully disagree point by point:

"The X-Play GOTY awards are not intended to validate the opinions of others, it is intended to bring notice to achievements we find worthy of special commendation."

I completely agree. Speaking of special commendation, those same 3 GOTY winners in years past have not only won the GOTY award, but other G4 awards; even including genre awards for their game. Fable II did not. In fact, Fable II did not even win its own genre category; which went to Fallout 3.

Posted by GamersVoiceOfReason - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 9:22 AM

Before I hand down my gauntlet of reason, I will gladly admit that Fable II was a very good game. It could have easily won GOTY any other year.....except this one.

I noticed that Adam Sessler himself has tried to defend X-Play's decision on these awards by aiming the blame towards him. I'm going to respectfully disagree point by point:

"As Editor-in-Chief, I take ultimate responsibility for the decisions made in these awards. Let's funnel the blame in my direction, you know I'm used to it."

Unfortuntely, this is the hardest statement to stomach. I've seen Sessler Soapbox segments PRAISING Grand Theft Auto IV, Metal Gear Solid 4, and even Boom Blox. Anything on Fable II? Nope.

Posted by GamersVoiceOfReason - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 9:25 AM

As an added note for all the G4 watchers out there, can anyone name me the only game creator on this list that NEEDS to sell at least 3 million copies of his game in order to recoup production costs and get green-lit for another sequel? Peter Molyneux. I don't know about you, but it's a lot easier to sell 3 million copies of your game if you do a couple of interviews accepting awards for your games that can't even win your own genre awards.

Epic Fail.

Posted by GamersVoiceOfReason - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 9:29 AM

As an added note for all the G4 watchers out there, can anyone name me the only game creator on this list that NEEDS to sell at least 3 million copies of his game in order to recoup production costs and get green-lit for another sequel? Peter Molyneux. I don't know about you, but it's a lot easier to sell 3 million copies of your game if you do a couple of interviews accepting awards for your games that can't even win your own genre awards.

Epic Fail.

Posted by Bahamet678 - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 9:31 AM

Like everybody else says, fable 2 should not have won GOTY, it would have been nominated though. My bets would have been on GOW2, fallout 3 or MGS4. And i thought TF2 would have won best multi. fable 2 for GOTY is all shnitz-an-giggles

Posted by Ieyke - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 9:34 AM

Wow.....the moron brigade is out in force on here.

Chill the hell out guys.

Posted by BONERJAM - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 9:36 AM

I'm a little suprised by the selections but whatever. Personaly I would have picked Fallout 3 for GOTY. Also, I find it hard to believe Left4Dead is the best shooter, from the time I spent with L4D I thought the controls sucked.

Posted by Lightmike578 - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 9:37 AM

WTF

Posted by ZCube - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 9:38 AM

even though i thought that it was overrated if gta 4 was released later in the year it probably would of won game of the year. overall that games reviews were better than all the other on the list

Posted by Smartguy81 - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 9:38 AM

@GamersVoiceOfReason
He did do a soapbox on fable2. It was focused on its accessibility and the fact that his wife who really is a non-gamer enjoyed fable2.

Posted by zaffelkid - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 9:40 AM

I never watch xplay for game ratings! Fable 2....shipoopi! lol

Posted by Smartguy81 - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 9:41 AM

@thundercracker
I enjoyed the game more so than Fallout3 and Resistance2, and to a point more so than Gears2. Honestly if R2 or Gears2 would have won...this board would have a hell of a lot more posts than it does now.

I'm glad that Fallout3 didn't win.

Posted by that311guy123 - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 9:48 AM

Well this just makes me even more excited to play it once my room mate gets his 360 and Fable II this weekend!

But what was with there being no best fighter category? I'd give to to SSBB.

I was fully expecting MGS4 to win, wild

Posted by garrettkers - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 9:50 AM

im glad it was not MGS i thought that game was gonna win best racer as well

Posted by madlexxx - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 9:51 AM

FABLE 2??? WTF??? are you serious?????

Posted by GamersVoiceOfReason - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 9:59 AM

@Smartguy81

Absoultely correct. Has been noted.

To that point however, you would think based on his glowing commentary of the game that Fable II would have at least walked away with one other award other than GOTY. He called it a great RPG, did it win RPG of the year? No. He gleamed about how innovative it was in attracting non-video game players. Did it win the best Original or Innovative game awards? Neither.

Posted by gspider - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 10:04 AM

Hey guys imagine, xplay say Fablo2 is a game of the year, how many copies are going to be sold for Christmas, I bet they have a good piece of the cake. Even they have this guy fable 2 producer at the end of the show, everything was fix.

Posted by Ieyke - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 10:13 AM

@BONERJAM: WTF?
It has the EXACT same controls as TF2, HL2, Portal etc etc.
It is the same legendary control setup that all Valve's shooters use.

Oh wait. Maybe you played the 360 version and it sucked. That wouldn't surprise me. All Console FPSs are inferior.

Posted by gspider - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 10:18 AM

Hey guys imagine, xplay say Fablo2 is a game of the year, how many copies are going to be sold for Christmas, I bet they have a good piece of the cake. Even they have this guy fable 2 producer at the end of the show, everything was fix.

Posted by gspider - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 10:20 AM

I know what happen Adam is really the Joker, and GOTY is just like the Joker say " Part of the Plan "

Posted by Kn0w13dg3 - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 10:26 AM

I do not understand this at all. I thought these people were gamers. I own 360 & PS3 and I agree with most of you that MGS4 should have won. And I would make a strong argument about Fallout 3, but it was just missing something. Who were the individuals that decided this? Did they just put all the games in a bag put a blind fold on and pull one out & it’s the winner?

Posted by ThataUFO - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 10:33 AM

@leahy

So dude, how's the babysitting going?

Posted by Smartguy81 - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 10:33 AM

@GamersVoiceOfReason
I think it is acceptable for a game to not win its single category and the GoTY category. Simply put we can analyze the game for how good it is instead of the genre it is supposed to fit in. Fallout3 is definitely more of an RPG than Fable2...so picking Fallout3 over Fable2 in that category makes sense. GoTY is what an editor/consumer/critic deems best all around to them. While Fable2 might not have had the best rpg elements, story, fighting system, writing, whatever...it all did come together to form quite a nice package. I'm not saying those elements in Fable2 were bad...just that individually there was another title in each category who was a cut above.

Posted by deleted_C6C9089C-D6DC-4922-B1C3-8A403A6CE8BC - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 10:35 AM

Well Fallout3 beat fable2 as best RPG but fable2 beat it in GOTY, prob cuz fallout3 is also on the ps3 and they wanted a M$ exclusive, why does G4 hate ps3?

Posted by shroomguy - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 10:44 AM

THIS NEVR HAPPENED. NOPE. NOT AT ALL.

Posted by BONERJAM - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 10:48 AM

@Ieyke

I love the HL2 engine and all those games but L4D is slightly different. I guess what I meant was really not the control but the movement. It seems like no matter how little you try to move you run. I get that the game is fast paced but my friend and I both felt like your character is the Flash on ice skates.

Posted by Kratosgodnutz - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 10:58 AM

X-pLay is the new Fox News. Fair and Balanced!!! Not. These guys are clearly biased toward X-Box so it would only seem fit to award GOTY to Fable 2. Good old Peter probably has them in his pocket. I am shocked that Too Human didn't win since they had Dennis Dyack on the show about 1 million times.
Only person that seems genuine or know what he's talking about is Adam Sessler.

Posted by theg3neral - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 11:00 AM

The Best Racing Game should have been Midnight Club: Los Angeles

Posted by Korwyn - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 11:06 AM

I kinda doubt the method of choosing GOTY.

GOTY isn't even the best game in it's own kind.
GOTY doesn't even win most awards.
GOTY almost didn't win any other elements which makes GOTY e.g. best writing, best game play, best art, best soundtrack. It just appearantly became GOTY from out of no where.

I think there might be one missing award they forgot to mention. The most generous game company of the year.

Yup, it's microsoft.
why?
because
microsoft helps restoring E3. :o) right right right?

Posted by DaSaintFan - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 11:17 AM

Honestly, I can only see two categories i can "Really" argue with...

Downloadable content: Rock Band? I know they have a lot of DLC, but you still have to pay a fortune to make a large collection. Burnout on the other hand, basically gave you an entire "new" game for absolutely free if you bought the original.

Best Sound Design: MGS4 ? Really? (and I am a huge MGS fan... (I'd have probably given them the writing award) I think g4 missed the mark totally on this one. Dead Space gives you the sounds and atmosphere of being trapped on a space station...

Everything else I can see an argument for (even if I don't agree with the choices).

Posted by GameMistress - Wednesday, December 10, 2008 11:27 AM

Fable 2 seriously??? Over Gears of War 2 or GTA 4 or Fallout 3 or... well, I could keep going, bec