Youens' infatuation with Boyer began in high school, but according to Remsburg, Boyer never even knew Youens.
"He mentions in the website [...] that he was in her algebra class in the 10th grade and that's where the obession began," Remsburg said. "The teacher said her name, he looked up and said 'Amy,' and he looked over and that was the Amy that he remembered.
"From that point on, he followed her around school, watched her in the hallways, watched her on the bus, paid attention to everything she did," Remsburg continued. "But she never had any idea this kid was out there."
All the while Youens was stalking Boyer, methodically, both off- and online. He was also stockpiling a cache of weapons in his bedroom, including AR-15s, semiautomatic rifles.
"[The AR-15s] shoots a projectile or a round that travels at 3,200 feet per second," Paison said. "That weapon was made to kill people. It is not a hunting rifle; it is not a target-shooting rifle. The only purpose that it serves is an anti-personnel and anti-human being weapon."
Youens' website proudly displayed the weapons, including the gun that was ultimately used to kill Boyer. A photo of it was posted alongside chilling details of his fixation. He wrote, "God I love her..." and "Why don't I kill her too?" on the site.
The website also details the killer's stalking patterns. He wrote that he planned to kill her outside her home. However, he ultimately decided upon a different location because, during several surveillance sessions, he saw her father's truck parked outside the house. He assumed the family was on to him.
"He wrote in his website, 'I cannot do this here,'" Paison recounted. "'I must find somewhere else.' He then put a search out for her employer's address. All these research companies came back with, 'Can't find. Not enough paper trail on this young woman. We need more information.'"
Desperate to find out where Boyer was working, Youens went online and bought her Social Security number for less than $50 -- which ultimately led to her location.
"After several weeks of logging her hours [and] learning her schedule, on the 15th of October he was there waiting for her when she got out," Remsburg said. "And that was the day she died. And what upsets me is these companies just sell all this personal, private information. They sell Amy Boyer's Social Security number, and they have no idea who the man is they're selling it to."
Remsburg is also upset that no one, including the Nashua police department, knew about the killer's website prior to the murder -- even though it was live on the Internet for years.
"No one in Nashua knew it, most certainly the police didn't know it, the Remsburgs didn't know it," Paison said. "Possibly he communicated with people out there. We know he did have a conversation with [someone] in Europe who may have actually seen this website, but didn't take it seriously. But no one in this area had ever seen this website."
"When this first happened and the police called us to the station the night of the murder and told us what they found in his room and they found these websites, I was, I was just so angry," Remsburg said. "How could this information have been out there for two and a half years and nobody made a phone call, no one's responsible for this?"
